-1

I was taught to say "It's a good soup", "It's a great car", "It's a really good weekend" whereas I was watching a movie last night where a guy was eating a soup and said: "It's good soup".

How to tell when we should use the a article or not in such a scenario? Or maybe what's the difference to a native speaker (if any)?

  • Depends on if you are considering soup as a substance (eg, water) or as an object (eg, a car). This is good soup would be a better response. – Vishnu Jul 25 '17 at 4:53
  • Sure, you are right, because the word "soup" is uncountable. – Łukasz Szkup Jul 25 '17 at 5:28
2

Use the article when it is countable. Soup can be used in either a countable or non-countable sense.

If you refer to soup generically, such as the type of liquid in your bowl, it is non-countable, so you would say "this is good soup". Similarly, if you are talking about a restaurant that does a good job preparing soup, you might say "they make good soup".

It becomes countable in some special cases. For example, you're judging different soups in a taste-off. If one of the soups is good, you might say "this is a good soup"; it's countable in the sense that it is one type of soup in a collection of different types of soups.

People sometimes use "a soup" when referring to a standard serving of soup. For example, when getting a can of soup from a vending machine, or ordering a serving of soup in a restaurant ("I'll have a soup").

However, you wouldn't typically refer to that as "a good soup" if it was good. "A good soup" uses "good" in the sense of a category of soup, which is a different sense from a unitized portion of soup. The article doesn't do double-duty. If you got a unitized portion of soup and it was good, you would typically say "this is good soup".

If the quality of the soup is hit-or-miss and today's serving happened to be good, you might say "this is a good soup", but the reason would be similar to the taste-off case -- it's one example of soup from the good category, rather than being related to the unitized serving.

The use of the article is based on the context, whether the point of the sentence is to convey something about soup in a countable or non-countable sense.

1

The difference may seem subtle. It is somewhat subtle.

The difference between the two ("It's good soup" vs "It's a good soup") is the introduction of the determiner "a". In this particular case you could use either. The "a" indicates that it's some type of soup - "a soup". While saying, "It's good soup" just remarks on that specific soup" (that you are eating).

You may still be confused and scratching your head because you are thinking isn't that the same for both? As I said, in this case, but not always, they both work. However, the "a" stresses the types of soups, whereas the one without the "a" just remarks on it being "good soup".

  • To me "It's a good soup" implies something like "This recipe is a very successful one." – Kate Bunting Jul 25 '17 at 13:12

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.