First, I have to admit that I don't know a good term to refer to this case, nor do I have a concrete example. Everything is just from a vague memory. So if you can correct me or suggest a good correction, please feel free to do so.

I believe that I have sometimes come across a sentences in which the authors have some sorts of list of descriptions but only form a full clause for the first item of the list, and leave the second and third with just [subject object]. I don't know if it is a correct (and good) thing to do, but it amuses me somehow and I'd like to understand it better.

The sentence is something like this (this is my example, I don't have a good recall what I have come across):

Bushes should be categorized as trimmable, while trees (should be categorized) as obstacles, and grass (should be categorized) as terrains.

My sentence could be a lousy one or in the context that can be written in this way, but hope that you get my point

EDITED: keeping "as" as suggested

  • 1
    I think they would/should leave the 'as' in there: '...trees as obstacles...' – marcellothearcane Jul 4 '17 at 20:34
  • Bushes should be categorized under 'trimmable', trees under 'obstacles', and grass under 'terrains'. // This is not relevant to the English involved, but this is a classification error: a worse example would be classifying cars as '4-wheeled', 'three-wheeled', and 'red'. – Edwin Ashworth Jul 4 '17 at 20:55
  • 1
    @EdwinAshworth Excuse-me, I don't really get what you are suggesting! – AugLe Jul 4 '17 at 21:15

This is a specific type of ellipsis, gapping. According to Wikipedia:

In linguistics, gapping is a type of ellipsis that occurs in the non-initial conjuncts of coordinate structures. Gapping usually elides minimally a finite verb and further any non-finite verbs that are present.

As it says, it's the verb that gets elided, not prepositions (meaning you should keep "as", like @marcellothearcane said). Wikipedia has a similar example (subscript is the elided part):

Jim has been being observed by me, and Tom has been being observed by you


From the tags it seems you already know the term—ellipsis. Here's a live example for you from The Devil's Dictionary:

EDIBLE, adj. Good to eat, and wholesome to digest, as a worm to a toad, a toad to a snake, a snake to a pig, a pig to a man, and a man to a worm.

@marcellothearcane is correct in suggesting to keep the as before every entry.

You shall find more examples in classic English literature of the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries.

EDIT: Here is another example I have just read in As a Man Thinketh:

The dishonest man may have some admirable virtues which the other does not possess; and the honest man obnoxious vices which are absent in the other.

EDIT2: Here is a classic quote for you, from Francis Bacon:

Reading maketh a full man; conference a ready man; and writing an exact man.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.