1

Does anyone know whether "batter" as in "batter up!" on a baseball field is a noun or a verb derived from a noun?

To test for its verbhood, you'd have to apply some verb-related tests. Can it have a tense ending attached to it, for example? But if "Batter up" is generally used as a command, then that test is not available.

If it is a noun, then can you provide other examples of the pattern Noun + up that are used as commands?

I've found some examples, such as

"it's time to batter up and play ball."
--from Google Books

"It’s time to batter up and make that homerun!"
--from a Realty One Group webpage

"...like Babe Ruth from a New York Yankees baseball match, we batter up and knock those curveballs right out of the park."
--from Google Books again

If this sort of sentence works, that'd be evidence for its verbhood.

I'd appreciate your help.

  • There are also tests for adjective-hood, preposition-hood, and even negative polarity, but before applying any such tests one would have to have sufficient motivation to believe the word might be an adjective or a preposition or a negative polarity item. Similarly for verb. I see zero reason to even suggest the batter in "batter up" who is a baseball player, a person, is a verb. Can you share your thought processes on why you think it may be a verb? – Dan Bron Jun 29 '17 at 10:40
  • 1
    @terdon It is used to call a batter to bat. If you like trains, it's equivalent to all aboooooard. – Dan Bron Jun 29 '17 at 10:43
  • 1
    If you think the term is ambiguous, more context will help. – Lawrence Jun 29 '17 at 10:46
  • 4
    Perhaps this could be clarified by translating the phrase to the game of cricket, in which it would be "Batsman up!". Batsman/batter is simply a noun referring to the player at bat. The whole thing is basically a set phrase that's short for "The next batter is up!". – Nuclear Wang Jun 29 '17 at 13:28
  • 1
    Oh! You're not a native speaker. And presumably not a baseball fan. That's why you don't have the mental image that makes it clear that it's a noun. The words mean a specific thing to native speakers and baseball fans, and that meaning is what I've described above; the mental symbol being manipulated is indeed the batter, a person. It's a noun. – Dan Bron Jun 29 '17 at 15:24
-1

First, "batter" is a noun derived from a verb (bat, which in turn is a verb derived from the noun bat).

Second, the examples given don't seem to have been addressed previously. They all could be read as referring to a completely unrelated form of "batter", the dough you fry food in. By context, that's clearly not what's meant though. They are using "batter up" as a verbal phrase. But they do not make "batter" itself a verb.

"Batter" as a verb usually has a another completely different meaning (hit repeatedly). Again, by context not what is meant.

| improve this answer | |
-2

'Bat' started as a verb (Old French 'battre', to strike) {cf. 'beat', 'butt'}. It then auto-derived to a noun, to name the stick used for striking. This takes the suffix '-er' to make the noun 'batter', one who strikes. There is another noun 'batter', stuff that is stirred, that could conceivably be used as a verb {cf. "He buttered the bread."}, but that is the wrong context for baseball. "Batter up!" is an imperative, like "Heads up!", calling the next batter to the plate. The elided verb is 'be' {cf. "He is up"}.

| improve this answer | |

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.