1

I have come across a number of questions on the site recently where someone asks how something is pronounced. Someone will give a sample word to illustrate the pronunciation (e.g., a rhyming word for a vowel sound or one in which the relevant consonant sounds the same). Someone else will point out regional variations where the pronunciation is very different, so the sample word is useless as a "universal" example.

An illustration: There was recently a discussion about Mary/merry/marry/Murray pronunciation. I commented about "marry" rhyming with "Barry". Someone pointed out that in some places, "Barry" rhymes with "berry", if I remember correctly. So I offered "Sally" as an example of the "a" sound, just guessing that there isn't much variation in pronunciation.

There was another recent question about "gin" vs. "jean", and tchrist commented, using "fleece" and "kit" as examples. Those seem like pretty safe word choices. Were they good guesses or are those "standard" words that are known to have pretty universal pronunciations?

Most people are not familiar with the letter-like codes used to document pronunciation in places like dictionaries. I assume that there must be a reference to those symbols that says [X] is pronounced like the [Y] in [WXYZ]. The choices for the WXYZ words must be words where at least the relevant portion of the word is universally pronounced the same.

Is there a collection of such "WXYZ" words that can serve as universal examples of what I mean as to how a vowel or consonant sounds?

  • 2
  • @vickyace, thanks. I'm amazed that there are only 20 vowel sounds and 24 consonant sounds. I expected such a list to be much longer. And even in that "standard list" there are different UK vs. US pronunciations for some words. So it looks like there may be no universal words for some sounds; maybe the best I can do is use a standard word + UK/US designation. – fixer1234 Mar 31 '17 at 5:21
  • 1
    And then I read the footnotes. – fixer1234 Mar 31 '17 at 5:28
  • 2
    @sumelic, another resource I wasn't familiar with. Thanks. For non-English majors, this stuff is not common knowledge. I suppose for site regulars, my question is like "Is there a book where I can look up the meaning of words?". :-) – fixer1234 Mar 31 '17 at 5:51
  • Kenyon & Knott is online now (that's American English, not British). It's the standard pronouncing dictionary, and uses this phonemic system, which is mostly IPA symbols. – John Lawler Apr 2 '17 at 17:20
1

"Fleece" and "kit" are part of the Wells "lexical sets." They have been used somewhat as a standard in some discussions about vowel sounds in different dialects, but of course they also have their limitations—Well's use of "palm" doesn't work for American English speakers who have /ɔl/ or /ɔ/ in this word, and the words "cure" and "tour" have different vowels for me and some other speakers (my pronunciation of "cure" sounds to me like it rhymes, or at least almost rhymes, with "fur", but I can't use my "cure" vowel in words like "tour" or "poor").

Wells's lexical sets are based on two artificial standard "reference dialects," "GA/General American" and "RP/Received Pronunciation".

Wells wrote a blog post in 2010 ("lexical sets") where he explains some of the thinking behind his choice of words:

I wanted words that could never be mistaken for other words, no matter what accent you pronounced them in.

Although FLEECE is not the commonest of words, it cannot be mistaken for a word with some other vowel; whereas beat, say, if we had chosen it instead, would have been subject to the drawback that one man’s pronunciation of beat may sound like another’s pronunciation of bait or bit. As far as possible the keywords have been chosen so as to end in a voiceless alveolar or dental consonant…

though that was not always possible. The least satisfactory keyword is PALM, and its set is also fairly incoherent. Amy says she prefers to replace it with FATHER, which is fine up to a point: but not if we are discussing Hiberno-English, where father often has not the expected aː of Armagh, Karachi, Java etc but the ɔː of THOUGHT.

  • I had forgotten about this question. Thanks for closing the loop on it. – fixer1234 Sep 11 '18 at 3:13

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.