English Language & Usage Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for linguists, etymologists, and serious English language enthusiasts. It only takes a minute to sign up.
Sign up to join this community
I said to a person that she is "chubby" and, apparently, she took it very seriously. What I meant to say is that she's not skin and bones, she carried more pounds than needed but, precisely because of that, she should be actually more attractive.
In Italian I would say that she is "in carne" but I don't know its English equivalent. Is there a word for it in English?
Anything can be offensive, or not. Offense is in the mind of the subject, and may take intent of the speaker into account.
In my particular culture (Western Canadian Anglophone Caucasian, which overlaps with lots of other cultures, especially throughout North America), at this particular time (2010's, but extending back for quite a few years), I would expect a significant number of women to take offense to being called "chubby", even if it was not intended to offend, and especially if they did not have a very familiar relationship with the speaker.
For what it's worth, most adjectives implying overweight would also be considered offensive to varying degrees. Being overweight is one of the most sensitive personal issues (especially for women) in my current culture & time. In fact "overweight" is probably one of the terms least taken in offense -- which is why I'm using it.
The term "chubby" would generally be only used to refer to babies or small children and even then some parents may take offense.
Some positive terms used to describe a pleasantly plump woman (in order of safety: safest to use first):
As you can see from the definitions, if you want to make a positive statement about a woman's plumpness then you are also making a statement about their sexual desirability in your eyes.
I am from New Zealand and most woman who are on the plump side would probably appreciate one of these terms being used in connection with them. Most would not appreciate being called "overweight": in some cultures here curvaceous is considered just the right weight. In fact, I'd say that "curvaceous" would be the safest term. I'm not sure this is also the case in the USA.
A note on bodacious: I don't think it refers to a woman's curvaceousness, but just her attractiveness. Definitely nice to be described as bodacious though.
Yeah, chubby isn't very tactful. It isn't offensive in the sense that cursing or swearing is considered offensive but it certainly isn't going to do much for her self-esteem.
Honestly, I don't know of any way to refer to not-skinny that isn't going to be at least awkward. My opinion is to refer to her as not being too-skinny:
I like that you aren't skin and bones
Some girls are far too skinny
Then again, this isn't really my area. I just avoid the topic if at all possible. In America, at least, the whole subject is typically considered a taboo.
Chubby is in most cases going to be taken offensively in North America. It would be associated with being overweight when applied to an adult. Possible alternatives that sound more flattering could include "well proportioned", "curvy", "shapely", (more colloquially) "carrying it in all the right places", and possibly some others.
Source: Personal experience courting women :P
There is a lot of psychology at play here and what she'll take badly depends on the lady, but you might consider "full figured" instead.
Lets see some other choices include
I usually say squishy, thick, solid or cuddly to avoid using the word chubby. I have also been known to use 'pleasantly plump' as Tom Au suggested.
The word bodacious evokes the 80s for me. I still love to be called bodacious. It feels more exciting, and it feels positive. For me, bodacious is the flattering substitute for the word chubby. But that is just me; I am rather biased. ;D
What I meant to say is that she's not skin and bones... some more pounds than needed but, precisely because of that, she should be actually more attractive.
Never say to any woman who is not already your girlfriend or wife that she is chubby. And even then, say it in a sweet, affectionate and gently teasing way so she won't burst into floods of tears and accuse you of being mean, heartless and insensitive. Some women will take a different approach and refuse to speak to you for the rest of the day or start reading the invisible list of faults you possess...
If a man had written this I would have have accused him of sexism but as it's me and I belong to the category of "not a skinny bird" I can safely say this.
Chubby is not complimentary; it means someone who is overweight, soft, round, and definitely on the heavy side. It is not the same as "in carne" an expression which I personally dislike, but for Italians it tends to have more positive connotations.
To compliment a woman on her figure because she is not "skin and bones" you could simply tell her she looks healthy. Not particularly exciting compared to curvaceous; curvy; voluptuous; full-figured (potentially on dangerous ground with this one); and "curves in all the right places". But if a woman is not thin and looks "normal-sized", (i.e. size 12 and above) healthy is a safe option.
N.B. There's nothing wrong with saying she is sexy and hot either, regardless of her body weight, but that implies you are sexually attracted to her and depending on circumstances it might be considered inappropriate or creepy and offensive at the worst.
The type of word you would use is largely on the context. I'd map out three groups to describe weight:
If how you feel about how someone looks is relevant to the conversation, you might say that they're voluptuous. If you concerned about their health, you might say ... well, you get the idea.
No, I wouldn't use "chubby."
The term I would use is "pleasingly plump." Even that may get you into "trouble" for implying that someone is "heavy." But at least you've sugarcoated it with a compliment.
The issue isn't so much the word as the concept. This causes a euphemism treadmill effect, where new words brought into service as less-hurtful versions of "fat" quickly adopt its bad connotations and are themselves replaced.
This isn't an issue so much of using the right or wrong word, but rather in that situation she would have probably been upset no matter what word you used to express that.
Word choice still does matter, calling someone "chubby" is generally less offensive than "fat."
But generally in American culture, many overweight people will get upset if you make any kind of mention regarding their being overweight, especially if they don't know you very well.
