0

Sentence in question

The widest range of books are/is available here

Should I use are or is there?

Case for are:

The article the: hence the noun phrase (range of books) in question is countable and since it is plural(books) so are is to be used.

I have no arguments for is.

Kindly correct me and provide some general guidelines for the subject–verb concord for the relevant cases.

1
  • It's normally the head of a subject noun phrase that determines the verb-form. The head of the noun phrase here is singular "range" so the verb-form should also be singular: "is".
    – BillJ
    Nov 14, 2016 at 8:17

1 Answer 1

0

Probably that should be is because the range is available. That of books part is not the head noun of the noun phrase, and the plural part is only the prepositional object. It is the head noun which is the subject whose number governs that of the verb, and that is range which is normally singular.

You’ll hear people say it the other way often enough, though, and there are cases where it actually does go the other way. You have to think about it a bit sometimes.

It may be that the speaker is thinking of range of the way they think of lot of, which would mean that range of would now be a pre-modifer to the (logical) head noun books, leading in that case to a plural, just like it does with a lot of people are as opposed to a lot of life is. But that might be hard to argue.

I’m not completely certain where superlative adjectives enter into this picture. I’m afraid any simplistic rule about them may lead you into confusion and error. Consider:

  1. The smartest children are the first to leave.
  2. The smartest are the first to leave.
  3. The smartest child is the first to leave.
  4. The smartest is the first to leave.

All are fine. The verb tells you whether the subject is being construed in the singular or plural. This is the speaker’s choice, depending on intent.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge that you have read and understand our privacy policy and code of conduct.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.