1

Specifically when they are used to refer to a person. While not listing them as synonyms directly, Thesaurus (adamant, tenacious) lists both as synonymous to strong-willed and several other adjectives that go in the same direction.

Is there a difference between the two words (specifically when referring to a person, but if you can think of other cases where both could be used with slightly different meaning, that's also good)? Does one of them maybe have a slight negative connotation?

closed as off-topic by FumbleFingers, user66974, jimm101, cobaltduck, curiousdannii Oct 29 '16 at 1:22

This question appears to be off-topic. The users who voted to close gave this specific reason:

If this question can be reworded to fit the rules in the help center, please edit the question.

  • 3
    Have you looked up the meanings in a dictionary. They are quite different. – Mick Oct 28 '16 at 15:48
  • 3
    In practice they may both describe the same person's attitude, but in principle if he's adamant he's inflexible (resists attempts to make him change). If he's tenacious he keeps a firm grip on his current position (resists attempts to make him let go). Either term can be used descriptively, with no inherent implication of a positive or negative assessment. – FumbleFingers Oct 28 '16 at 15:57
  • 1
    @Mick They can both be translated as "hartnäckig" to German meaning someone who sticks to doing something even if they're not successful at it or it is very hard. This is the focus of my question, maybe not clearly asked, sorry. According to thefreedictionary.com tenacious fits that use better, but it also says "adamant: to be unshakable in ... determination, ...", which to me sounds very similar. Or am I understanding that wrongly? – user35915 Oct 28 '16 at 16:10
  • 1
    @FumbleFingers so someone can not be an adamant worker in the sense that they stick to a hard job? It was my understanding that both words can be used like that. – user35915 Oct 28 '16 at 16:23
  • 2
    Who tells you that "adamant" has the sense of "sticking to a hard job"? Read a few more dictionary definitions. – FumbleFingers Oct 28 '16 at 16:30
1

Merriam-Webster's Dictionary of Synonyms (1984) groups adamant with inflexible, inexorable, obdurate, and adamantine:

Inflexible, inexorable, obdurate, adamant, adamantine mean not to be moved from or changed in a predetermined course or purpose. All are applicable to persons, decisions, laws, and principles; otherwise, they vary in their applications. ... Adamant and adamantine usually imply extraordinary strength of will or impenetrability to temptation or entreaty [examples omitted]

The same dictionary groups tenacious with strong, stout, sturdy, stalwart, and tough:

strong, stout, sturdy, stalwart, tough, tenacious can all mean having or manifesting great power or force (as in acting or resisting). ... Tenacious comes very close to tough in its most general implications, but it places greater emphasis upon retentiveness of what has been gained or of adherence to a support, position, or idea; it carries a strong suggestion of holding on, of adhesiveness, or of maintaining strength or position in spite of all opposing forces that would dislodge , dispossess, thwart or weaken [examples omitted]When applied to material things and especially to substances it may suggest a powerful clinging quality and extraordinary resistance to forces that tend to effect separation or pulling apart [examples omitted]

So, according to this dictionary, the core difference in the two terms is that adamant applies centrally to resistance to being moved (physically or figuratively), while tenacious applies centrally to resistance to being separated from something (physically or figuratively).

S.I. Hayakawa, Choose the Right Word: A Modern Guide to Synonyms (1968) places the words in somewhat different families. Hayakawa puts adamant in a group with stubborn, headstrong, obdurate, obstinate, pertinacious, and pigheaded:

All of these words suggest a tendency to persist in an opinion, belief, decision, or course of action, generally with more force than reason. ... Adamant implies a hard and unyielding attitude that may be the result of a strongly felt or carefully thought out conviction regarding some important matter: [example omitted].

Hayakawa associates tenacious with willful, firm, hard-headed, hard-nosed, no-nonsense, strong-willed, and tough:

These words all describe more or less uncompromising or fixed states of mind. The differences between them reveal that obstinacy in itself can be adjudged either good or bad, depending on the motive behind it and the uses to which it is put.

... Tenacious, meaning tending to hold strongly, as opinions, rights, etc., is also much favored by men and women in the public eye: [example omitted]. Tenacious has the implication of hanging on, refusing to let go no matter what the odds against eventual victory. This can be interpreted as blind stubbornness or as fierce devotion to right principle. Nevertheless, the word always conveys some respect; a tenacious adversary, for instance, may be disliked but he is certainly not to be taken lightly.

Thus, although Hayakawa yokes the two words in question to some rather unsavory synonyms (adamant to pig-headed, for example, and tenacious to hard-headed), the book acknowledges that people sometimes use the words in an admiring way—as descriptive terms for someone motivated by “strongly felt or carefully thought out conviction regarding some important matter” (adamant) or by “fierce devotion to right principle” (tenacious).

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.