1

This question already has an answer here:

I'm trying to update punctuation in an older children's book, and I can't find an answer to my question regarding the punctuation in this passage:

“Well, well! if we wait there until summer comes, our shoes will get dry of themselves.”

Should the "if" be capitalized or left as is?

marked as duplicate by jimm101, Drew, Scott, Mitch, tchrist Oct 15 '16 at 0:49

This question has been asked before and already has an answer. If those answers do not fully address your question, please ask a new question.

1

Interestingly, capitalisation after exclamation or question marks is a relatively modern thing, if you look in Charles Dickens, for example, he doesn't capitalise after such punctuation.

In regard to your specific question, I think you have three options:

  1. Leave it

If you want to be as true to the originals as possible, you could leave the punctuation and not capitalise the succeeding letter. Since exclamation marks are used frequently in this book (I presume Rico and Wiseli by Johanna Spyri) Frequent capitalisation may interrupt the story.

  1. Capitalise

As this is a children's book, teaching them a form of punctuation that is archaic and no longer used is a possible worry. Furthermore, it makes sense to stick to more modern rules to keep the story up to date.

  1. Leave it and use [sic]

This might be a slightly odd solution and I would advise against it on the whole. If you are updating the book as a whole it is simply impractical, however, if you are quoting the book, particularly if it is in more academic literature, using sic is considered the appropriate way to show that a sentence has been translated without any changes.

Personally, I would leave it (although I am a traditionalist) and make some reference to this issue in the editor's notes.

  • @Beckylou Great! Up-vote and accept the answer if you agree with it and to stop the question from being bumped up. – BladorthinTheGrey Oct 14 '16 at 15:53

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.