3

And you may not really expect an answer or want/need an answer. Not quite rhetorical. For example you may be talking about something that happened and wondering who did it and everyone knows who did it including yourself but you ask, 'I wonder who that was.'

  • Why do you have to wonder who did it when you know who did it? – Nagarajan Shanmuganathan Sep 23 '16 at 4:41
  • @Nagarajan Shanmuganathan You're not wondering who it was. You're stirring things, using a common strategy. – Edwin Ashworth Sep 23 '16 at 7:21
  • As in it was unintentional? Like you did not intend on a rhetorical question? I would call that an impulsive statement (question). – user189910 Sep 23 '16 at 9:31
  • Or as in you are interested in an answer you already have? – user189910 Sep 23 '16 at 9:32
  • 3
    This is exactly what a rhetorical question is. It is a question asked to make a point. It doesn't matter whether you go on to provide the answer explicitly or not -- although that is also a type of rhetorical question, providing a pretext to explain. – Andrew Leach Sep 23 '16 at 10:30
3

A question where one does not want or need anyone to supply an answer is a rhetorical question.

The rhetorical device is either for the question to make its own point, because the question is left hanging for its hearers to consider, or to provide a pretext for its asker to answer it and make his point with that statement.

The rhetorical question is usually defined as any question asked for a purpose other than to obtain the information the question asks.

Gideon O. Burton, Silva Rhetoricae, Brigham Young University. Rhetorical questions

1

It depends upon your motive for asking...

Perhaps Machiavellian - practising, or characterised by, (esp. political) expediency in preference to morality; unscrupulous, duplicitous; astute, cunning, scheming (OED).

0

One who is doing this is probably testing the water; perhaps they are just itching to name you-know-who (as an example) but hesitant and looking for (potential) supporters before they are seen as voicing their opinion openly. If someone else falls for it and opens up, they then can just second them (with the confidence that they are not the first to face the consequences, if any).

ODO:

test the water: Judge people's feelings or opinions before taking further action.

0

This is called a

"Who's buried in Grant's tomb" question

You can also react to the question, after you or someone else has asked it, by saying

Duh!

to show that you just realized the answer was obvious. This is a fairly recent thing, and it might just be for the U.S., I'm not sure.

"Duh!" is usually said with a certain musical inflection in the voice, and may be accompanied by a heel of the hand tap to the temple. Optional variant:

Well, duh!

Edit: one more -- a vapid question

(offering nothing that is stimulating or challenging)

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.