1

In my opinion, we could say "..sleep with your closed/open mouth."

Please explain to me why we use adjective closed/open after the noun mouth? Please tell me the difference between the two usages.

3

Saying "You should sleep with your mouth closed" means that when you sleep your mouth should be closed. Saying "You should sleep with your closed mouth" means that sleep is somehow called for due to the fact that your mouth is closed.

With modifiers(**) like open/closed the presence of the modifier before the noun implies that the modifier is describing the current state of the noun -- in effect selecting which possible version of the noun is being referred to. With the modifier after the noun, on the other hand, the implication tends to be that the object identified by the noun should have it's configuration changed to what the modifier describes.

** I use "modifier" because I don't want to get into a discussion as to whether it's an adjective or some form of verb.

1

"Sleep with my open mouth" seems that there may be an open mouth that I can bring to bed.

"Sleep with my mouth open" seems that I have one mouth which I left open.

  • We also say "Sleep with the window open/closed" for the same reason. Taking a double-glazing salesman's sample to bed with me wouldn't help with the ventilation at all! – BoldBen Sep 15 '16 at 7:09

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.