2

Consider the following two sentences:

[1] The boy is coming.
[2] The boy is singing. (at the same time)

How can I join the two sentences using a participle? Can I use any of the sentences below?

[3a] The boy comes singing.
[3b] The boy is coming while singing.
[3c] The boy is singing while coming.
[3d] The boy is coming singing.
[3e] The boy is coming, singing.

8
  • 3
    "The boy is singing while he comes." is the most clear, I think, but "The boy is coming, singing." has a nice poetry to it. Jul 25 '16 at 8:55
  • 6
    Be aware that the verb to come has a slang meaning.
    – deadrat
    Jul 25 '16 at 9:01
  • 2
    @Deadrat - why do you think it is not the intended meaning ?:)
    – user66974
    Jul 25 '16 at 9:41
  • 1
    @Josh61 Probably a projection of my own lack of musical talent.
    – deadrat
    Jul 25 '16 at 9:48
  • 1
    3a is also clear to me and the most succinct
    – NibblyPig
    Jul 25 '16 at 10:00
1

As English has very limited inflectional morphology, sometimes it becomes really difficult to recognize finite verb form the non finite (verbals). The poster poses exactly that glaring problem area.

We know finite verbs are bound in time, space and aspects in its relation to subjects; verbals have no such obligations.The paradox of the situation is such that COMING / SINGING both qualify as finite verbs and one AND in-between is enough to solve it. But the environment surrounding the verbs is proof enough what is what :

  • Is coming — tensed participle

  • Singing —Verbal(non finite)

We are not bound by any rule to put these lookalikes together and we must not with due respect to their functional disparities and sanctity of semantic order.

Make SINGING the head word, the problem is solved. All other sentences where meaning can easily be gathered and which are not strained, reflect the sense to be convyed ; but never in "COMING SINGING" combination.

2
  • Coming is not a tensed verb; it is a non-finite verb form that carries no tense. Came, in contrast, is a tensed verb.
    – tchrist
    Nov 3 '16 at 21:00
  • We ordinarily consider the verb phrase, ' is coming ' as the verb in making present continuous tense; it may be treated from common man's perspective. Great things are too great for me Nov 7 '16 at 17:19
0

This might seem old-school but: "The boy comes a singing"

2
  • I'd go past "old-school" to "archaic" :) Jul 26 '16 at 13:25
  • hyphenate that: "he comes a-singing"
    – Dannid
    Oct 13 '16 at 16:03
0
[3b] The boy is coming while "he is" singing.
[3c] The boy is singing while "he is" coming.
[3e] The boy is coming, singing. 

I think this sounds ok. But I guess you must use "he is"

2
  • Sorry. I forgot it @janus-bahs-jacquet
    – John Doe
    Aug 1 '16 at 8:32
  • @Zan700 That was edited in after my comment. I'll delete my comment above since it's no longer relevant. Nov 7 '16 at 19:07
0

[3a] "The boy comes singing."

Grammar ok, Comparable to "Come dancing!" or "I come bearing gifts".

[3b] "The boy is coming while singing."

Grammar ok. Comparable to "The boy is drinking while driving"

[3c] "The boy is singing while coming."

Grammar ok. Comparable to "The boy is coughing while serving food."

[3d] "The boy is coming singing."

Incorrect

[3e] The boy is coming, singing.

Grammar ok. Comparable to "The boy is leaving, carrying his suitcase, laughing as he goes."

To put together "sing" and "come" a little better, use "as", without the second present participle:

"The boy is singing as he comes through the door."

"The boy is coming forward as he sings the last stanza"

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.