6

I grew up in Kalamazoo, MI, where (according to Wikipedia and other sources), many speakers have something called the Northern Cities Vowel Shift (NCS). So I'm trying to figure out if I'm one of them.

I'm running into two difficulties with this:

  • The written descriptions of it all seem to be from the standpoint of, and written for, people who unambiguously don't have it; they'll say things like "they pronounce job like jab", meaning "NCS speakers' job is somewhere between non-NCS speakers' job and jab".
  • According to everything I've read, one interesting difference between NCS and most other regional accents is that people from regions with NCS speakers don't notice the difference; NCS and non-NCS both sound the same to them. (And that's true of me; I certainly don't notice anything strange about non-NCS speech, but when I tried watching a Youtube video of examples of it, I found that several of the examples sounded completely normal to me.)

So, how would I go about figuring this out?

  • Do you speak any other languages? – phoog May 11 '16 at 5:22
  • A fellow Michigander here would also like to know. – curious-proofreader May 11 '16 at 5:26
  • 1
    @phoog: Hebrew and French well, and a bit of Spanish. But I'm not sure if that'll help at all: English's vowel space is very different from any of theirs, so I think the difference between NCS and non-NCS Midwestern accents will be trivial by comparison. (Also, ideally I think an answer here should be useful to anyone else with the same question, whether or not they speak any other languages.) – ruakh May 11 '16 at 5:28
  • 2
    I found the audio test which the first link talks about. Fun to hear and do! pbs.org/speak/ahead/change/vowelpower/vowel.html. If you don't make any "mistakes" in the transcription, you're probably a NCS speaker, I guess. I had to click on the hint link to "guess" the word, 4 out 5 correct. But without the hint, it would have been 0/5 – Mari-Lou A May 11 '16 at 7:34
  • 1
    @Mari-LouA: Oh, and -- thanks! Would you like to turn that into an answer? – ruakh May 13 '16 at 4:33
1

I'm also born and raised in Kalamazoo, MI. From my understanding of NCVS, I don't think I have it (can't entirely decide), but I'm sure my parents don't.

Considering my friend group of people who are from the cities (excluding suburbs) of Chicago, Detroit, and New York (the Bronx), I find NCVS:

  • very noticeable from New Yorkers
  • not at all noticeable from Detroit people
  • somewhat noticeable from Chicagoans

Interesting, since Kalamazoo is the half-way point between Chicago/Detroit.

0

I agree with Nenookaasi. I grew up in the Detroit metro area and do notice a different pronunciation between people from Chicago and New York. I do not think people in the lower peninsula have the pronunciation you describe.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.