3

I'm struggling with the word "burden" used in a phrase: whether it should be followed by the word "on" or "to." It might be obvious to some of you, but I am not a native speaker. Or maybe there is another preposition that is more appropriate. I am willing to listen to your ideas.

The specific sentence I'm using "burden" in is:

"Laws...will help the progress in human advancement rather than becoming a burden (to/on) civilization."

1

The word "burden" has an etymology originating from "to bear", I am thus convinced that "on" would be a more appropriate preposition.

Beside the etymology, I feel like taking a stab at the reason why this sentence is confusing by examining the word "becoming".

The phrase is "becoming a burden _ civilization". If one focus on the partial phrase "burden _ civilization." The preposition "on" may be more obvious, but in the context of the full phrase, one can just as well interpret "...a burden" as an attribute to the verb "becoming". For example, "becoming a man" is different from "becoming a dog" because the object into which the subject has become is specified, and one may understand "becoming" as a somewhat isolated action. For many verbs that do not have their own special preposition, "to" is used to agglutinate a verb to a target. So, if the original sentence is understood as:

"Law becomes a burden, and this action has effect against civilization."

Then the preposition "to" may be plausibly used, but if it is understood as:

"Law becomes some burden, and this burden is specifically a burden on civilization"

Then the preposition "on" would seem appropriate with respect to etymology.

Finally, the preposition "of" may be used in lieu of the other two.

  • Welcome to the site, and good answer! – OldBunny2800 Feb 29 '16 at 4:38
0

I would say it really depends on the context of how you're saying it.

"A burden to do something"

Would simply mean that it is a rigorous task, and is not something one would choose to do. This could be dishes/laundry as a young child, or even going to work if you of age.

"A burden on someone"

Seems to mean that someone/something has become a bother (to the point that it is irritating seeing that item.) It would be the same as someone constantly being in the way of plans wanting to be made, or even something as simple as a family member having to be taken care of by a loved one.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.