2

The sleeping babies are adorable.

and

The babies sleeping are adorable.

To me, the two sentences are identical in meaning. However, this doesn't seem to be the case in the following sentence:

The singing sensation is a teen heart throb.

and

The sensation singing is a teen heart throb.

To me, the subject of the first sentence is a singer whereas the subject of the second sentence is in the process of singing.

Is there a rule for when using a present participle as an adjective does not carry the same meaning as doing a whiz deletion?

  • 1
    The singing sensation is an NP where the verb "singing" is modifying the noun "sensation" (i.e. it’s adjective-like), but The sensation singing, is a clause with “The singer” as subject and "singing" as verb. This is evident from the fact that it can be expanded into The sensation singing Sinatra songs wonderfully at the Palais last night where "Sinatra songs" is direct object. Only verbs take objects. Same applies to your "babies" example, cf. the noun phrase The sleeping babies and the clause The babies sleeping peacefully in their cots. – BillJ Feb 20 '16 at 12:22
  • @BillJ you beat me to it by 34 seconds! – Mynamite Feb 20 '16 at 12:23
  • @Mynamite Sorry! – BillJ Feb 20 '16 at 12:29
2

I think your difficulty lies with the fact that singing sensation is a commonly used compound term, and therefore turning the phrase around has a different meaning. I couldn't find an online definition of "singing sensation", however a quick search will find many examples of its usage:

Singing sensation Susan Boyle has been awarded an honorary doctorate from a Scottish university.

There is even a website singingsensation

Sleeping babies is not a compound term, it is merely an adjective with a noun, and babies sleeping is, as you say, a whiz-deletion.

If you avoid sensation and substitute a different noun it becomes interchangeable the same as the babies example:

The singing man is a teen heart throb.
The man singing is a teen heart throb.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.