4

Please clarify the usage of right preposition on or at.

For example: That paper is on your desk.

or That paper is at your desk.

closed as off-topic by Mitch, Cascabel, David, Laure, NVZ Jul 12 '17 at 16:09

This question appears to be off-topic. The users who voted to close gave this specific reason:

If this question can be reworded to fit the rules in the help center, please edit the question.

  • It has to be on your desk. – Durga Swaroop Jan 13 '16 at 6:07
  • @Durga, not necessarily (see my answer below) – Chris H Jan 13 '16 at 8:07
  • @ChrisH Yes, I agree. But, still I would say on is more specific. But, if you just want to convey that it is at the desk and not the specifics, then i guess at can be used too – Durga Swaroop Jan 14 '16 at 5:31
  • @Durga being specific (and correct) requires more knowledge (or more tidiness than I have), e.g: Laptop - on or (in bag) under; Book - on or (on shelf) beside. – Chris H Jan 14 '16 at 7:38
  • 1
    In my experience, objects are on a desk (if they're physically on it), and people are at a desk (if they're seated in front/back of it, depending on your point of view). – Brian Tung Jan 14 '16 at 21:19
6

The prepositions

  • at implies spatial location, or directional.
  • on implies vertically atop.
at:
  • He is at home.
  • She is at work.
  • They are at Walmart.
  • People are looking at us.
at (idiomatic)
  • While we're at it, I might as well remind you to flush the dang toilet every time.
  • I am hacking at the problem now.
on:
  • She is sitting on the chair.
  • We are on the hilltop.
  • The cat is on the fridge.
on (idiomatically on top or over)
  • I am on the problem now. Don't worry.
  • He is speaking on the history of the Roman empire.
  • The television channel comes on air at 5 am.

Therefore, see the difference ...

  • She is sitting at my desk.
  • She is sitting on my desk.
  • The boy is speaking at his mother's desk.
  • The boy is yelling at his mother's dog.
  • The boy is yelling on his mother's desk.
  • The boy is speaking on his trip to New Zealand last week.

The paper is {on/at} your desk

  • Idiomatic use of desk = a virtual work space, especially in news reporting or editorial endeavours.

    • The news desk of Larry King. The latest edition of today's events is at Larry's desk.
    • Please make sure any submission for drafts of your novels are at the editor's desk before 2016/01/31.
    • The paper on the advantages of CMOS analogue design should be at the conference submission desk by noon Aug 1, 2016.
  • Physical desk

    • He found the paper at his desk. I have no idea if he found it on, under or beside his desk. But it is on his desk now.

Today, Harry will be speaking on his desk being burned to ashes last week. He intends to sit on his desk when he speaks on his no longer existent old desk. He will be telling us on his old desk, like as though he is telling on us to our boss. He will be telling on his old desk about all the secrets it held.

Since he will be targeting at his old desk, he might as well be telling on the hatred he thinks his desk had on him. Since he will be at his old desk, he might as well be on his old desk, on their mutual love-hate relationship with each other, while sitting on his new desk and delighted at his new desk.

In fact, he was at his new desk this morning writing his speech on a piece of paper. That paper is now on his desk. He plans to submit it to CNN's news desk hoping they would publish it. But we know it won't be on CNN, because such a silly paper will never be found at CNN's news desk.

  • Does on imply "vertically atop" in There is a fly on the wall? – GoDucks Jan 18 '16 at 0:05
  • 1
    On the wall is a nearly an idiomatic use. When you look at a notice board tacked with all kinds of memos, and you can't see your memo - then someone yells at you to say, "Your memo is underneath the poster. Someone has tacked a poster on top of other people's memos." Despite that the notice board being vertical on the vertical wall. – Blessed Geek Jan 18 '16 at 4:02
3

The correct usage is:

That paper is on your desk.

The preposition at is used in a slightly different situation:

You should be at your desk during office hours.

  • 3
    To clarify, people are at their desks. Objects are on or in those people's desks. – Steven Littman Jan 13 '16 at 18:41
2

In American English we would almost always say

The paper is on your desk.

and on is used when we refer to something being in contact with the surface of an object. This often means on top of a surface, such as a desk. This can also refer to a vertical surface, as in The fly is on the wall.

At is used to specify a location as a point in space. It just means where your desk is. It does not mean on top of your desk, like on your desk would usually mean. We might say the guest is at your desk. Or maybe the umbrella is at your desk. Technically, we could say the paper is at your desk but it is not idiomatic.

  • Thank you very much for the explanation. The usage of on / at is more clear to me now. – Frency Jan 14 '16 at 8:21
1

On is most likely right in this case but not necessarily. If it's on the bookshelf next to your desk, and you're in another room, at your desk is just enough information for your colleague to know how long it will take to fetch it. If it's in the desk drawer, at, in and under are all more appropriate than on. It would be unusual to use anything other than on for an item to which it was definitely applicable, or could be assumed to be applicable, such as a keyboard. If you said on when it wasn't literally true, the only person who would be bothered is someone you'd sent to look for it.

I'm used to southern British English, some relevant influences here may be engineering terminology, and large open plan offices ("at my desk" would be equivalent to "in my office" or even "in my cubicle")

  • In ordinary use, the only thing AT someone's desk is the person who uses it. Everything else should be more location-specific. The paper is on the desk, the stapler is in the desk, the computer tower is under the desk. For a paper to be AT a desk would be highly unnatural usage. – Steven Littman Jan 13 '16 at 18:41
  • @StevenLittman, maybe it's the variant of English I'm used to or maybe in my field we leave more, bigger items at our desks, but in my experience "at" isn't unusual. I agree that for the specific example of a paper, either "on" or "in" would be more appropriate. – Chris H Jan 14 '16 at 6:43
  • @Chris H--it would be helpful if you'd identify which variety of English you are used to. It seems to me that the guideline I stated is fairly basic and therefore I would think it was universal. – Steven Littman Jan 14 '16 at 19:21
  • @Steven, edited in (S. UK), also note about why I might be familiar with this use. – Chris H Jan 14 '16 at 19:29

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.