7

/sæg/
/slænt/

Transcriptions from Cambridge American English Dictionary

Both the words' IPA transcriptions have an /æ/ symbol. Do those two /æ/s sound the same?

Are they both short or long?

Is /æ/ sound the same length in all the words?

  • 4
    It depends on your accent. To BrE speakers in the North of England, sag, slant, bath, etc., are all the same short 'a'. To southerners like me, ~*sag* is a short 'a', but the others are long (my bath is approximately your barf, except I don't go big on the actual phoneme /r/ either). – FumbleFingers Dec 30 '15 at 16:20
  • Possible duplicate of Why is the "a" in "have" a short a sound? – FumbleFingers Dec 30 '15 at 16:21
  • What? a in have has a short sound? – user152435 Dec 30 '15 at 16:24
  • 4
    Yes, in American English, "sag," "slant" and "have" use the same short "a." – Mark Hubbard Dec 30 '15 at 16:46
  • 1
    @FumbleFingers I don't think this is a dupelicate, because the OP asks if the sounds are the same (we can deduce from the transcription the OP is talking about Gen American). The answer is that they aren't likely to be the same sound although they will be allophones of the same phoneme. The vowel in slant will be shorter because of pre-fortis clipping. The one in slag will be full length. The vowel in slant will be nasalised, the one in slag won't be. Lastly, OP asks if the STRAP vowel will have the same length in all words. The answer is no: ... – Araucaria Dec 30 '15 at 16:47
16

Short answer

In most varieties of General American these words use the same phoneme, /æ/.

However the /æ/ in sag and the /æ/ in slant are different. The /æ/ in slant will be nasalised. It will also be shorter than the /æ/ in sag.


Full answer

In General American both these words use the vowel /æ/. [Some other varieties of English use different vowels in each word. For example, Southern Standard British English uses /æ/ for sag and /ɑ:/ for slant].

The Original Poster asks three questions:

1. Are these two sounds the same?

Although the vowels used in sag and slant will both be recognised as the same phoneme by listeners, they will have substantially different qualities.

Probably the most important difference will be that in the /æ/ in sag, the air is likely to leave almost entirely through the mouth for the duration of the vowel. In the word slant the velum (the little flap of skin hanging down from the back of your mouth) will start to prepare for the nasal sound, /n/, during the vowel stage. It will lower, allowing the air to escape through the nasal cavity. As the air passes through the cavity it will give the vowel a characteristic metally twang that we recognise as nasalisation.

If we recorded someone saying the word slat, for example, and then the word slant, we could play back just the beginnings of the words without the final consonants and a listener would recognise which word was being said. The nasal quality of the vowel would tell them, for example, that this word was slant, not slat.

2. Are they both short or long?

For a so-called 'lax' vowel, the vowel /æ/ is quite long. This is probably because the articulation requires quite big movements of the mouth. The lips need to stretch quite wide and the jaw needs to drop quite low.

However, the actual length of this vowel will be significantly different in the words sag and slant. A normal, canonical /t/ is unvoiced (the technical term is that it is a fortis consonant). When unvoiced/fortis consonants occur at the end of a syllable, they have a strange effect. They make the preceding vowel and any other voiced sounds much shorter. So the vowel in slant may be up to 50% shorter than the vowel in sag - which ends with a notionally voiced /g/. (The technical term for consonants which are notionally voiced is lenis)

This shortening of vowels before voiceless consonants is known as pre-fortis clipping.

3. Is /æ/ sound the same length in all words?

Apart from pre-fortis clipping there are in fact several other factors which can affect the length of a vowel. One of the most important of these is rhythmic clipping. The more syllables after the main stress in a word, the shorter that stressed syllable will be. So the /mæn/ in the word manager has a much shorter vowel than the /mæn/ in the word man.

Another factor that could affect the length of the vowel is whether it is the nuclear syllable in the sentence (whether it has the main musical stress). The nucleus of a sentence may be much longer than the other syllables depending on the intonation.

Advice to learners

It is not a good idea to try and adjust the length of your vowels to take into account complex factors such as prefortis clipping, for example. Pre-fortis clipping occurs crosslinguistically and you will automatically produce a shorter vowel before a fortis consonant without trying. It's much more helpful to get a feel for the comparative length of a vowel in relation to other vowels, in my experience.

  • 1
    I wish I could upvote this answer more than once. This is the kind of answer that benefits the entire community, not just the OP. Thank you. – Nonnal Dec 30 '15 at 18:21
  • 1
    Brilliant answer, Araucaria. I used to be an amateur recordist and even did a little voice-over work back in the day, but I have never taken analysis of my own voice (or anyone else's) to this level. I'll have to listen to some of my samples to determine if I can discern the differences you hear. Thank you for constructing such a useful answer for all of us. – Mark Hubbard Dec 30 '15 at 20:40
6

In many speakers in the Midwest and West (particularly the Upper Midwest and the Pacific Northwest), the vowel /æ/ in sag, slag, bag, tag, and so on, is diphthongized1. It can be the same as the /eɪ/ in vague, or it can be pronounced similarly to the way Australians pronounce mate /mæɪt/. See this dialect blog entry.

1It is also diphthongized in sang, hang, rank, blank, and so on. But I believe that this pronunciation is so widespread that most Americans don't notice it.

2

The two sounds are the same phoneme: no two words are distinguished by using one sound rather than the other. What exactly a given /æ/ will sound like depends on its phonological context, as well as the speaker’s dialect.

As with snowflakes, no two instances of a phoneme are exactly alike;[1] the exact sound of a given phoneme depends in part on the surrounding sounds. As Araucaria has pointed out, some of these differences in pronunciation are automatic, such as nasality and length. Such adjustments follow rules that exist across multiple languages. It’s completely normal for a vowel to receive some nasal coloration from a following nasal consonant; you don’t need a language-specific rule for that, and hardly anyone except a linguist would notice it. You shouldn’t try to consciously adjust your pronunciation to account for such differences.

However, some varieties of English (or any language) have very distinct allophones used in specific contexts. Dialect-specific allophones are not necessarily automatic, and you may want to be consciously aware of them. Taking our specific example: many dialects pronounce /æ/ as a diphthong in very specific contexts. Exactly which contexts these are is a matter of regional variety.[2] In my own Mid-Atlantic variety, I pronounce the phoneme as [eə] before the nasal consonants /n/ and /m/ – but not /ŋ/. For me, this only happens in closed syllables; for example, I pronounce Ann as [eən] but Anna as [ˈæ.nə].


[1] It really is a marvelous thing, the ability of humans to categorize speech sounds as phonemes! Sounds come out of our mouths (or signs from our hands) in continuous streams, yet we automatically and unconsciously split up the stream into discrete phonemes. Phonemes are abstractions; they don’t exist in time and space, and yet every day we rely on their existence. Each instance of each phoneme is unique and colored by the surrounding sounds (or signs), and yet we know right away that a given sound is, say, an /æ/ and nothing else.

[2] See Pronunciation of English: /æ/-tensing on Wikipedia

  • 1
    Let me give you a very long overdue upvote. How come I missed your answer before? – Araucaria May 25 '16 at 13:34

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.