1

Can the word 'erroneous' be used to apply to a person, as in the term 'erroneous spouses'?

  • 3
    'erroneous spouses' meaning what? Spouses who were mistaken about something? Spouses who weren't really spouses? – Rand al'Thor Dec 14 '15 at 0:58
  • I could see literary or flowery prose where "erroneous spouses" was being used to say that someone had married the wrong person. – Cargill Dec 14 '15 at 3:16
4

Tl;dr: erroneous is now rarely applied to people; use "mistaken" unless you have a good reason. The brave may continue reading.

The OED finds the only uses of erroneous not obsolete or archaic are applied to "doctrines, opinions, and statements," where the word means mistaken. The sense of "morally faulty" is marked "Obs. or arch." but has the virtue of Lord Byron's use in Don Juan in 1819:

Haidée and Juan were not married, but
The fault was theirs, not mine; it is not fair,
Chaste reader, then, in any way to put
The blame on me, unless you wish they were;
Then if you 'd have them wedded, please to shut
The book which treats of this erroneous pair,
Before the consequences grow too awful;
'T is dangerous to read of loves unlawful.

In a separate sense of misguided (and equally unused), the OED quotes Sir Thomas More from 1829:

He who shows himself grievously erroneous upon one important point must look to have his opinions properly distrusted upon others.

A more modern source, the 2005 novel Little Fugue by Robert Anderson describes passengers on a delayed train

good-naturedly swapping stories about getting lost amid the London miasma, entering the wrong flat, and sleeping with the erroneous spouse.
"The Mister's had the sack over me head for twenty-five years anyhow." a charwoman's voice joked from the economy seating.

Here the word is humorously applied to the spouse mistaken for, not the spouse making the mistake.

In a more serious vein, from 1977, The Journal of Libertarian Studies:

The erroneous person allows a whole host of fleeting temptations to divert himself from his own true goals.

The google reveals that the term "erroneous spouse" is almost a term of art on online genealogical sites to describe an ancestry tree that wrongly records a marriage.

1

Short answer is: no.

Erroneous should be used to describe something that is incorrect.

  • An unfaithful spouse, however, can be and often is described as an errant spouse, which derives from the same root, to err, meaning to wander. – Brian Donovan Dec 14 '15 at 1:17
  • How about a person who uses "erroneous" erroneously? – Hot Licks Dec 14 '15 at 1:22
  • @HotLicks, Send 'em to walk seven times around the seven hills of Rome. – Brian Donovan Dec 14 '15 at 1:49
  • @BrianDonovan They could probably use the fresh err. – PlasmaStarfish Dec 14 '15 at 2:21
  • @PlasmaStarfish Actually, I pronounce err to rhyme with fur. As for the hills of Rome, I could have gone with a quotation from Singin' in the Rain (Moses supposes erroneously) but opted instead for A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to the Forum, in the film of which the role of Erronius was played by the great Buster Keaton. – Brian Donovan Dec 14 '15 at 3:13

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.