3

He can watch me clean the car.

In this sentence, the pronoun me is used as the object of the verb watch. But isn't me also acting as the subject of the verb 'clean' and therefore should be I instead? Obviously 'he can watch me clean the car' sounds correct but why is it this way? Is there a rule that governs this?

Reopen note

This question has been linked to this question here:

However, that question is clearly about whether to use an infinitive or a gerund-participle form after the verb hear. This question is as described above. It is about the function of the pronoun me in sentences like the one described.

  • 1
    No, me is not acting as the subject of the verb clean. Very simple test: do you watch him clean the car, or do you watch him cleans it? Did you see us clean the car, or did you see us cleaned it? – RegDwigнt Nov 18 '15 at 12:24
  • 2
    This is a different question, surely? In my opinion, this one is about catenatives and raised objects, not infinitivals vs participials. – BillJ Nov 18 '15 at 13:13
  • 1
    @RegDwigнt Erm, that's a pretty dodgy test. Are you arguing that she is not he Subject of the verb leave in It's essential that she leave immediately ? – Araucaria Nov 18 '15 at 13:33
  • Not enough room here to post a reply to the OP's question. – BillJ Nov 18 '15 at 13:46
  • @BillJ It's now open for you to give an answer. – Araucaria Nov 18 '15 at 23:17
2

"me clean the car" is an infinitive phrase as the object of the main verb. The subject of infinitives is always in the oblique case.

sbj: He
vrb: watched
        obj: me clean the car (infin)

Other examples of infinitive phrases as objects:

My mother made me take the trash out
She wanted us to come
We asked him to go home
0

In 'he watched me clean the car', 'I cleaned the car' is an event that is the object of the verb 'watched'. The form is called 'raising to object'. The sub-subject is in object case and the sub-verb is infinite (tense is implied by the main clause).

0

As pointed out by @William, the object complement clause me clean the car has me as a subject.
It also has an infinitive verb phrase without the normal to complementizer.
As pointed out by @Ami, this construction is called "raising to object" (or B-Raising).

B-Raising produces a noun phrase in the ideal position to function as object of the upstairs clause and subject of the downstairs one as well -- at the end of the first and the beginning of the second.
Since there are two parsings available, both can be used, and often are.

  • [1 He watched [2 me 1] clean the car 2]

B-Raising also produces a construction that's essentially identical to B-Equi, like

  • [1 He told me 1] [2 (for me) to clean the car 2]

where me in fact occurs twice, as the indirect object of told, and also as the subject of clean. I.e, it was me he told, and it was me cleaning the car; B-Equi is why me occurs once instead of twice.

So there are tests for Raising, which are explained in the link above.
And sense verbs like watch have special codicils, like omitting the for-to infinitive complementizer.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.