1

Longman Dictionary says:

that should do it also that ought to do it (spoken):
used to say that you will have finished doing something if you just do one more thing:
I've just got to prepare the dessert and that should do it.

So you should say it before the last part of the job is done. But many times I've encountered this idiomatic expression that it was said after the job was finished off. I did a search in Google Books:

  • The airplane kept climbing. That should be high enough, I thought. The plane continued to climb. That should do it. But no, we continued ascending. C'mon, we're really high enough already! Hey!

Furthermore, this usage is suggested by all the answers to this question. For example:

If I bake a cake, let it cool, put icing on it and add some decorative sprinkles, after the final sprinkles are added I might step back, examine my cake and say, "That ought to do it!" Which signifies both to myself and anyone present that the cake has now been completed to my satisfaction and is now ready to be eaten.

So there should be no doubt that "that should do it" could mean "that should have done it". I have two question:

1- Is it used before the last part at all? (as Longman Dictionary claims)
2- Why is it in the present tense? Why isn't it like : "that should have done it"?

  • It seems that "do" is a substitute for "finish". When I use the expression I use it when I'm about 90% certain that a task is complete, but not entirely positive. If I were 100% certain that say... my pig had learned to herd sheep and won a competition thus redeeming my faith in him and my own standing in the community I'd say "that'll do pig, that'll do" because "will" is more positive than "should". "Should" always leaves room for doubt. – Misneac Nov 15 '15 at 20:36
1

In my view,

  1. Yes, the Longman Dictionary usage seems right and in my experience, I have seen this phrase used like that. Most often, it is said just after doing the last part. Like once, I forgot to tip at restaurant, and waitress was mentioning that it is customary to tip, and one of my collegues added few dollars extra and said "That should do it"

  2. "that should have done it" seems more apt when, even after doing the last part, something was not accomplished. Something like "I posted the mail, and that should have done it. However, the mailbox was inoperative and it never got sent"

  • We can use 'should have' to talk about past events that did not happen. We can also use 'should have' to speculate about events that may or may not have happened (or, so is said here). But I agree that the fact that it's said just after doing the last part, prevents the use of "have". Thanks. – Færd Nov 15 '15 at 17:55

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.