6

Why is someone who is pedantic called a pedant and not a "pedantician"? If a person working in obstetrics is an obstetrician, why is not a person working with words not a pedantician?

6

Because the derivations are going in opposite directions.

Pedant comes from Italian pedante, a teacher; in English it means someone who shows off his/her knowledge and constantly tries to "teach" other people, even if they don't need it. (It does not mean someone working with words, although almost everyone on this site has a touch of pedantry now and then.) If you're being pedantic, you are acting like a pedant.

An obstetrician, however, is a person who works in obstetrics. "Obstetrics" comes from Latin obstetrix meaning "midwife"; the male form of obstetrix should be "obstetor", I think, but no such word exists. Instead, we have "obstetrics" (the duties of a midwife) and "obstetrician", one who performs those duties.

  • Pedant comes from Italian or it comes from French or maybe both. – AmE speaker Nov 1 '17 at 1:23
  • @Clare - Perhaps I should have said "from Italian, by way of French"; most etymology sources show it appearing in Italian first, then being borrowed into French. Maybe we got it from the French, maybe we got it straight from Italian; at the time it first appeared in English (around 1560), Italian literature was as commonly read in English high society as French (if not more so. – MT_Head Nov 1 '17 at 2:07
3

The reason there is no such word as "pedantrician" lies in the difference between the word pedantic and obstretics.

"Obstetrics" is a noun, and "pedantic" is an adjective.

"Pedantic" is derived from "pedant", but "obstetician" is derived from "obstetics"

The reason there is no "pedantrician", is because "pedant" is not a study, unlike "obstetrics." No one is an expert or a doctor or practices in "pedant"

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.