0

This is a comprehension cloze question for 11 year olds: "His only hope for cure was a bone marrow transplant. His brother was chosen to donate some of his bone marrow. The ________ would take place in the States.

Was told that 'transplant' and 'procedure' can be accepted but 'operation' cannot because patient won't be cut.

Is it really so?

  • Certainly "procedure" is the more general & encompassing term, but, as commonly understood, "operation" could apply since anesthesia would be used and the two bodies would be "violated" with catheters larger than a typical hypodermic needle. – Hot Licks Oct 22 '15 at 18:06
  • (I've had over a dozen "procedures" to remove kidney stones, and while a surgeon never used a scalpel on me in any of them, I would defy you to claim that they could not be called "operations" -- operating table, general anesthesia, surgeon doing the work, several nurses and technicians assisting.) – Hot Licks Oct 22 '15 at 18:33
2

The relevant definition of operation in Merriam-Webster's Eleventh Collegiate Dictionary (2003) doesn't mention cutting as a prerequisite:

operation n ... 4 : a procedure performed on a living body usu. with instruments esp. for the repair of damage or the restoration of health

Under the Eleventh Collegiate's definition, a bone marrow transplant would certainly be an operation; in fact, it might be viewed as two operations—one on the donor and one on the recipient. Any more-precise notion of the meaning of operation as a medical term of art involves a more sophisticated understanding of the term than Merriam-Webster seems to possess, and I think it is asking a lot of an eleven-year-old to be expected to possess it.

This is not to say that the operation in question may not also be characterized as a procedure.

0

As answered by @SvenYargs, "operation" is fine.

However, you may say:

"The transplantation would take place in the States".

Comparing the 2 nouns "transplant" and "transplantation", my feeling is that the noun "transplant" better fits to the therapeutic method and that "transplatation" relates more to the operation.

-1

An operation is generally understood to be a procedure that is performed by a surgeon.

And a surgeon is the person who generally does the cutting, as you put it.

So with that in mind, I would agree with the person who gave you the advice.

  • You probably need to say in this answer that a bone-marrow transplant usually doesn't need and isn't performed by a surgeon. You obviously know that, but if a reader thinks that it may be because they don't know what the procedure entails, this answer isn't very clear. – Andrew Leach Oct 22 '15 at 18:30
  • Peripheral blood stem cell (PBSC) donation is a nonsurgical procedure to collect blood-forming cells for bone marrow transplants. Bone marrow donation is a surgical procedure that takes place in a hospital operating room. – Graffito Oct 22 '15 at 19:51
  • You need some sources for your answer. eg. dictionary definitions. – dwjohnston Oct 22 '15 at 22:52

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.