6

Is "I am extremely smarter than you." a grammatically OK sentence?

It sounds awkward, but is there a grammatical issue?

Please note that I am not asking if it could sound better, nor am I asking for suggestions on an equivalent but better written phrase. Is this statement grammatically acceptable?

  • It does seem that only a restricted set of adverbs can modify comparatives. The tricky part is deciding if this set is grammatically restricted, or partially restricted by non-grammatical factors. Mention of this is made here (apparently it is much the same for adverbs modifying "too"): "too and too much", which lists much, a lot, far, a little, a bit, rather. Apparently, this class of adverbs may be called "adverbs of degree" (although I'm not sure; that might include other things too). – sumelic Oct 16 '15 at 3:39
  • Yeah, apparently "adverbs of degree" does include various words, including according to some "extremely." So it doesn't seem to be a helpful classification here. – sumelic Oct 16 '15 at 4:08
  • Another adverb that is acceptable modifying "too" or comparatives is almost. – sumelic Oct 16 '15 at 4:35
3

The statement is grammatically acceptable. (You can change "extremely"for "much" or "slightly"and see how it works ).It's the choice of an adverb that makes the sentence strange.

  • 1
    Are you sure? I would tend to think that one cannot modify a comparative adjective (probably not the technical term; I mean 'smarter' as opposed to 'smart') using the adverb 'extremely'. I agree that one could use 'much' or 'slightly', but I'm not sure that's conclusive; it is clear that one can say immodestly that "I am extremely smart", but I think that one cannot say "I am much smart." – LSpice Oct 16 '15 at 3:27
  • 1
    On the other hand, I've just checked and the OED does list 'very much' as one of the meanings of 'extremely' (oed.com/view/Entry/67170#eid4882154 ), so maybe I'm just overreacting to the awkward sound and making up rules that don't exist. – LSpice Oct 16 '15 at 3:29
  • @LSpice: I would say the sentence is more that just awkward; for me it's barely acceptable at the most. The tricky part is explaining this, and figuring out how the explanation relates to grammar (if it does). – sumelic Oct 16 '15 at 3:58
  • @sumelic Exactly, that's precisely why I asked the question. It just doesn't seem quite right, but it's hard to tell if it's actually wrong. – Jonathan Hebert Oct 16 '15 at 4:01
1

It would sound absurd when you modify superlatives with adverbs such as very/extremely/much, etc.

I am the extremely smartest guy in the world.

It doesn't work as superlative means:

The highest extent or degree of something.

I think the same way of thinking should be applied to comparatives. When you use comparatives, you have a certain extent or degree in your mind higher or lower, albeit abstract, and you want to express it.

Comparitive is defined in Merriam-Webster as:

of or relating to the form of an adjective or adverb that is used to indicate more of a particular quality

You want to express "more of a particular quality" and adding an adverb such as extremely can be a duplicate of comparatives.

That's why you don't use the adverb very to modify comparatives.

There are exceptional adverbs that are allowed by definition to modify comparatives such as:

Still, even, much, far, a lot, a way (colloquial)

Still has the following definition in Wiktionary:

(degree) To an even greater degree. Used to modify comparative adjectives or adverbs.

Those other examples have the same definition and usage examples as still. Extremely doesn't.

Note: You can google extremely + comparative and get some hits. I don't think people would be unable to understand when they are uttered. .

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.