0

In the following sentence, "People eat garlic when it is raw or cooked." is "when it is raw or cooked." an adverbial clause or an adjective clause? The way I see it, this clause can either talk about garlic or eating. Adverbs answer "how" questions and "when" can answer "how."

Other examples that fit this model:

"Vampires leave their coffin when it's dark." "When it's hot, I drink cold beers." "You use a pen when you are certain." "I get a cough when it's cold."

Is "when" a word that can introduce two interpretations of a sentence, a sort of "wavicle" (to borrow from the world of quantum mechanics)?

  • Let's have dinner when it is ready. Is this dependent clause adjective? – user140086 Oct 11 '15 at 3:41
1

I believe that the clause "when it is raw or cooked." is used as an adjectival as it modifies the noun garlic ( The status of garlic is either raw or cooked , it doesn't modify the action of eating

  • I tend to disagree. The fact that the clause is introduced by when suggests to me it is adverbial, since it is qualifying the verb eat. However if I said People eat garlic which is either raw or cooked - it becomes adjectival since it describes garlic rather than eat. I may be wrong - I am a native speaker and have never been required to distinguish the adverbial fro the adjectival. It just comes naturally. – WS2 Oct 11 '15 at 9:25

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.