0

Is this sentence correct as is, or should I remove the second has since that phrase is connected to the preceding one with and?

As Mr. X has replied your email and has requested the 'PDF files' of the project, here please find attached the requested files.

1

As Mr.X has replied to your email and requested the 'PDF files' of the project, here please find attached the requested files.

Of your suggestions, I prefer the above.

You may however mean,

As Mr.X has replied to your email, requesting the PDF files for the project, please find attached the requested files.

  • Both as good. But I pick the second one which sounds much better :) @chasly-from-uk – Electricman Aug 14 '15 at 23:08
3

You can generally conjoin two phrases of the same grammatical type to form a phrase of that same type, which can go anywhere either single phrase could go. This gives the following three equivalent ways of saying your example. I have indicated with brackets the structure of the conjoined phrase for each version:

[[As Mr. X has replied your email] and [as he has requested the 'PDF files' of the project]], ...
As Mr. X [[has replied your email] and [has requested the 'PDF files' of the project]], ...
As Mr. X has [[replied your email] and [requested the 'PDF files' of the project]], ...

  • I understand better now, Thank you. @greg-lee – Electricman Aug 14 '15 at 23:48

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.