-4

In my university, in English Grammar, I learned I can use "any" for negative and interrogative sentences and "some" in positive sentences, but when I watch English movies, "any" is used in positive sentences. So does this grammar rule have any utility?

  • 5
    They've told you the wrong rule, or else not enough of the right rule. There are two knds of any; one is "free choice" any (Take any one you want), which is not a negative polarity item and can occur outside a negative context. The other (and far more common) variety is the negative polarity item, which can be licensed by any negative trigger, and there are quite a few of them. – John Lawler Jul 30 '15 at 21:24
0

As you've stated it, the rule is completely wrong. However I think they are referring to this rule concerning the words some and any:

  • In the positive you normally say: "You took some cookies."
  • In the negative you normally say: "You didn't take any cookies."
  • In the interrogative you normally say" "Did you take any cookies?"

However there are lots of variants on this: "If you took any cookies..." is normal, and some people would say: "Did you take some cookies?", especially if it was "Did you take some cookies out of the tin?"

It's a decent guideline for getting the common usage, but it's by no means a hard and fast grammar rule.

Both some and any have plenty of other uses, and you shouldn't generalise to them.

  • What other usages have some and any, please? – anngela092 Jul 31 '15 at 21:24
0

Simply put.. (Keeping with the cookie theme.) You are somewhere with a few dozen cookies.

Someone says: "Have some cookies" - in this case, "some" means "not all". You may have some cookies, but not all. If you want two, then that is ok.

Someone says: "Take any cookie" likely means to take "one cookie"

"any" might mean "one" or "somewhere between 0 and all".

Other examples. At the car rental place, "I'll take any car." I've never heard "I'll take Some car".
"I need a volunteer. Any one will do." Therefore, I need one person. "I need some volunteers. Any one of you." I need more than one person and there is no qualification needed."

Most of the time, "some" and "any" are similar but not interchangeable. However, English is very forgiving in communicating understanding, even if it is difficult to get "right".

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.