11

I just came across the sentence

Like most people today, Judy was a cynic and was offended by the slightest hint of fantasy.

According to the dictionary, a cynic is :

a person who believes that people are motivated purely by self-interest rather than acting for honourable or unselfish reasons

Then, how does cynic fit into the above sentence?

Improve this question
  • 2
    cynical = bitterly or sneeringly distrustful, contemptuous, or pessimistic. – PbxMan Jun 23 '15 at 12:54
  • They like to criticize people and situations, especially if they think there’s a deeper motivation behind the more obvious one. – Misti Jun 23 '15 at 13:15
  • Anyone interested in the origin of the OP's quoted sentence can find it discussed in the final paragraph of a review of She's Funny That Way on the website HitFix. The reviewer there seems to share my sense that the sentence is at best problematic and at worst...I don't know—cynical? – Sven Yargs Jun 23 '15 at 16:41
  • What does the author mean by fantasy? – Mazura Jun 23 '15 at 20:21
16

There are three definitions of cynic, according to the American Heritage Dictionary:-

  1. A person who believes all people are motivated by selfishness.
  2. A person whose outlook is scornfully and habitually negative.
  3. A member of a sect of ancient Greek philosophers who believed virtue to be the only good and self-control to be the only means of achieving virtue.

Use of the word to mean the third of these is rare nowadays; the speaker of your sentence presumably had the second definition in mind, and you looked up and found the first. The historical note includes the explanation:-

When Cynic first appeared in English in the 1500s, it referred to the Cynic philosophers, but cynic and cynical were soon applied to anyone who finds fault in others in a contemptuous or sneering way.

So in this case Judy would be offended by a fantasy as she would be offended by, or affect to be offended by, anything else (finds fault...in a sneering or contemptuous way), and the more pleasant or agreeable the fantasy, the greater the scorn of the cynic.

Improve this answer
  • 2
    Can you add something about how a cynic (from #2) be then offended by fantasy? – Mitch Jun 23 '15 at 14:19
1

Well, Noah Webster's 1828 American Dictionary of the English Language actually has a very different definition of the word Cynic that's quite different from any other dictionary:

CYNIC, CYNICAL, a. [Gr., canine, a dog.] Having the qualities of a surly dog; snarling; captious; surly; currish; austere.

Cynic spasm, a kind of convulsion, in which the patient imitates the howling of dogs.

Translated into the modern tongue, they have a bitchy personality mate. People in a mean and sour mood, snappin' and snarlin' at whatever possibly just because they can. I suppose it's quite an apt and amusing way to describe the sort of people who are called cynical, although it does imply a bit more vigor than the gloomy tone we'd come to expect of the word now....

Improve this answer
0

Maybe the offended cynic does not have any imagination, and views products of the imagination with suspicion. Like so many modern people, the offended cynic refuses be reminded of the missing portion of their humanity, but prefers to accuse others of ignoble motives.

Improve this answer

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.