0

Is it normal to use the present perfect to confirm a statement in the simple past ?

Q : I visited Paris last year.
A : Oh, you have visited Paris ?

Q : She travelled through Eastern Europe.
A : Oh, she has travelled through Eastern Europe ?

1

It's all right to respond that way, since it's not a mistake, because your response is grammatically correct. However, as a learner, you might want to pay attention to the nuances there.

"I visited Paris." - This simply puts the emphasis on the verb, visited, may be for the first time, or it might serve as an answer to the question: "What did you last summer?"
"I have visited Paris." - The use of present perfect here means that I have gone to Paris in the past, and may be, more than once. It's a direct answer to "Have you visited Paris?"

That said, it isn't normal to respond to a question the way you've written. Usually, people responding spontaneously, say as follows:

"I visited Paris last year." - Oh, did you?

"I have visited Paris." - Oh, have you?

The same can be applied to your other example.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.