1

I encountered the word prohibited in some software documentation and am curious if this is an example of a double negative:

Prohibit requests for PROHIBITED parts

(This is an option in a piece of software; names omitted to protect the guilty.)

I found the wording confusing, though it sorta makes sense because I know that "PROHIBITED" is a type of status for parts in this system. I'm mostly curious from an educational POV.

Question: Is prohibit a negative word?

(This word must've been invented by a Marketing department: "because disallow sounds too negative!")

Follow-up question #1: Is there a better term for negative word in this context?

Follow-up question #2: Is there a[n exhaustive] list of negative words, or a guideline for identifying words as such?

By negative word I mean words such as not and no, and that can result in double negatives when used in a sentence.

  • prohibit (v.) early 15c., from Latin prohibitus, past participle of prohibere "to hold back, restrain" (see prohibition). Related: Prohibited; prohibiting. from etymonline, "prohibit" The word has it's positive connotations ie, protective. – user98990 Feb 24 '15 at 22:56
  • It sounds a little weird, but there's nothing wrong syntactically or semantically with "Prohibit requests for PROHIBITED parts", since "requests" and "parts" are two different types of entities. – Hot Licks Feb 24 '15 at 23:48
1

Yes, "prohibit" is grammatically a negative word, since it allows any forms and negative polarity items in its complement. "They prohibited us from swimming anywhere." "My uncle prohibited my mother from giving me a red cent." ("a red cent" in the non-literal interpretation appears only in negative contexts)

However, there is no rule in English against having several negative words appearing together.

  • Except that it doesn't always improve comprehension to have several negatives around. That's not grammatical, though; you're right. – John Lawler Feb 25 '15 at 16:37

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.