2

This question already has an answer here:

Please note: This may be a complex question, references would be great, search engines do not help with "of the".

Looks like we can remove the use of "of the" with a noun adjunct switching the order of a couple of names, at least sometimes. Examples:

  1. The name of the hotel → The hotel name
  2. The handle of the teapot → The teapot handle
  3. The use of the "of the" digram → The "of the" digram use
  4. The use of the digram "of the" → The digram "of the" use (?)
  5. The dog of the house → The house dog (?)

Looks like sometimes (when?) we need the use of the Saxon genitive. Examples:

  1. The dog of John → John's dog.
  2. The bag of the child → child's bag
  3. The beginning of the day → the day's beginning (?)
  4. The mistakes of the people → people's mistakes (?)

The questions are:

  1. First and foremost: is this correct? (or "what is incorrect here?")
  2. Which use is preferred? Using "of the" or the noun adjunct.
  3. What rules apply in this context?
  4. There may be some cases when the only correct option is using "of the", are there such cases?

marked as duplicate by Mari-Lou A, choster, Cascabel, jimm101, Spencer Feb 6 at 20:40

This question has been asked before and already has an answer. If those answers do not fully address your question, please ask a new question.

  • In a nutshell: 1. possessive/genetive versus preposition of; 2. Whether even the apostrophe-s can be dispensed with, at least in some cases? I suppose both points have already been dealt with here and in endless forums online. Any more questions? – Kris Feb 6 '15 at 12:16
  • Related: english.stackexchange.com/q/158306/14666 – Kris Feb 6 '15 at 12:19
  • And there's a whole tag -- possessive-s-vs-of english.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/possessive-s-vs-of – Kris Feb 6 '15 at 12:24
  • The first set of of-less examples are compound nouns which happen to be written with a space between the parts of the compound. Compare the stress on the first part of the compound "hotel name" with stress on the second part of "hotel's name". – Greg Lee Feb 6 '15 at 15:13
3

Most of your examples are 'correct'. However, colloquial, idiomatic English tends to avoid 'little' words. More often than not 'of the' is avoided. So the teapot handle rather than the handle of the teapot. This is especially the case in spoken English.

Although not necessarily the case, and easily over-ridden in spoken English, 'of the' can be used to convey formality and also for emphasis, (because word order guides understanding and the first noun in a string is assumed to be the dominant one).

The name of the hotel (emphasising name)

The beginning of the day (emphasising beginning)

The Name of the Rose (formal, poetic)

0

I am battling with similar issues. I am trying to help with your question (4). Unless you insist that it must be "of the", there seem to be a couple of cases where "of" is obligatory: "table of contents", "area of interest" (AOI), "Department of Defence" (DoD). It might be a case of Norman vs Anglo-Saxon English. Best regards,Johannes

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.