1

I just read "yet on the other hand" in a published research article and it seemed off to me. Is it just me? Is there a better alternative?

Specifically: The yet seems to be redundant to on the other hand and doesn't appear in the dictionary or typical examples I've seen that use on the other hand. Is it necessarily redundant? Is there a valid use case where yet is added to on the other hand?

  • 1
    However, what would a dictionary tell you about "on the other hand"? Please also check the English Language Learner's SE website or show your work :). – SrJoven Jan 6 '15 at 16:43
  • @SrJoven, the "yet..." part before "... on the other hand" is a part of what seems off and isn't in the dictionary or typical examples I've seen. – timothy.s.lau Jan 6 '15 at 16:57
  • That's often enough done. Maybe the yet didn't work in the context of the preceding and following text, which would make it seem off, but it certainly is okay in itself. – Jon Hanna Jan 6 '15 at 16:58
  • 2
    The "yet" seems redundant. "On the other hand" seems sufficient. – timothy.s.lau Jan 6 '15 at 17:02
  • 1
    The yet stresses the difference. I agree it's redundant and would personally recommending the writer cut it, but it's not incorrect to the point of being strange. – Jon Hanna Jan 6 '15 at 17:07
1

The following would flow better without the use of "yet on the other hand" (from your provided example):

On one hand, Some researchers (e.g., Lee, 2000) recommend that MLM only be used when the ICC is greater than .10, indicating that 10% of the variability is between psychotherapists. Yet on the other hand, in 2007, Roberts (2007) found that even when the ICC is near zero for a model with no predictors, “group dependence may still exist depending on the nature of the covariates introduced into the model” (p. 15), thus indicating a need for MLM with very small ICCs.

The following answer may also provide some insights: Academic way of saying "On the other hand"

1

Searching Google Ngrams indicates that on the other hand is currently roughly 1000 times more popular in books than yet on the other hand.

Searching Google Books proper seems to indicate some consistent usage of yet on the other hand where distinction in opposition is presented.

Arguably one's usage in literature does not necessarily imply correctness of use, but it does give credence to multiple authors' reliance on said usage, awkward or not, and alternative available or not, this is the structure chosen for this publication circumstance.

0

A word to preface (on the other hand): While on the other hand is how I've always heard it. The other way it can be said is "Yet at the same time..." ♥

0

Try the word 'however', and 'yet' and 'on the other hand' are redundant.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.