What exactly is the difference? Around the Web, I'm finding contradictory information and sometimes circular references.

Some say the lexicon is inherent to a language (objective) while a vocabulary is only relative to a (group of) person(s) (subjective). Wikipedia says the lexicon is the vocabulary of a language.

Dictionary should be an easy one, it's a mapping, either between languages or between words and word sense definitions. But some definitions of vocabulary seem to be equivalent to the latter.

Are there any clear formal definitions?

  • 2
    It's no wonder you're confused. As tchrist says, 'All these words have multiple senses, depending on the context and the domain.' The trouble is, they're usually bandied about in general English without particular usages having been specified. 'Interfrastically isn't in the dictionary.' Which dictionaries? 'Mens isn't in the English lexicon.' Says who? I see it used a lot more than say 'aardwolves'. – Edwin Ashworth Jan 4 '15 at 11:57
  • @EdwinAshworth The word mens may be most commonly encountered in English when used as part of the Latin term mens rea literally translated as “guilty mind” but now meaning criminal intent when used in the impenetrable legalese of criminal codes, attorneys, and jurists. Insofar as legalese is English and words used in English are English words, mens is therefore indeed part of the English lexicon, at least in one tiny, painfully abstruse corner. Then there’s the Latin aphorism mens sana in corpore sano, which is where I most often think of it. – tchrist Jan 4 '15 at 18:00
  • @tchrist The word 'mens' (I'm calling it a word because (1) it appears so often in various publications and internet articles and on signs, (2) the phenomenon of dropping apostrophes from 'non-ownership' Saxon genitives, eg dogs home, childrens books, is fairly well known and accepted by quite a few anglophones) is most often encountered in the UK in the compound Working Mens Club/s. – Edwin Ashworth Jan 4 '15 at 19:53

Asking for “formal definitions” is fraught with peril: who is the recognized authority? In any event, “searching around the web” isn’t going to do you much good. If you want to know what a dictionary says about a dictionary, then you shall have to actually use one. :)

All these words have multiple senses, depending on the context and domain:

  • Dictionary is not so simple as you seem to present it; your discussion of “mapping” suggests you are thinking more of a polyglot-type dictionary or else a computer dictionary, but neither of those are the most common current use for the word, which has a long history with many senses and subsenses.

  • Lexicon was historically used for “look-up”–type dictionaries for languages like Greek and Hebrew, but also has a particular sense in linguistics.

  • Vocabulary has at least four main senses, of which you allude to at most one. Sometimes it is just a word-list, but sometimes it is more than that.

Based on the assumption that the curated Oxford English Dictionary is a better primary source for words’ meanings in English than the crowd-sourced Wikipedia entries you stumbled upon, here’s an excerpt of what the OED says about all this.

I suppose you can take these for “formal definitions” if it pleases you to do so, but really they just document matters as the editors of the OED saw fit to do.

It should come as no surprise that the OED takes especial care delineating the historical and extended uses of its own name, dictionary. I’ve omitted a good bit of historical discussion from its excerpted notes below; see the real dictionary if you need that.

Truth be told, the note at the end of dictionary sense 1a is probably all you need, but I’ll include a little more than that just in case. The important paragraph that distinguishes one from the other I’ve highlighted in bold, but the other senses show how domain-specific use of these terms can be, well, more specific in that particular domain.

dictionary

Etymology: ad. med.L. dictiōnārium or dictiōnārius (sc. liber) lit. ‘a repertory of dictiōnēs, phrases or words’ (see DICTION) in Fr. dictionnaire (R. Estienne 1539), Ital. dizionario, Sp. diccionario.

  1. a. A book dealing with the individual words of a language (or certain specified classes of them), so as to set forth their orthography, pronunciation, signification, and use, their synonyms, derivation, and history, or at least some of these facts: for convenience of reference, the words are arranged in some stated order, now, in most languages, alphabetical; and in larger dictionaries the information given is illustrated by quotations from literature; a word-book, vocabulary, or lexicon.

    Dictionaries proper are of two kinds: those in which the meanings of the words of one language or dialect are given in another (or, in a polyglot dictionary, in two or more languages), and those in which the words of a language are treated and illustrated in this language itself. The former were the earlier.

    [...]

    Vocabulary is now generally limited to a smaller and less comprehensive collection of words, or to a word-book of technical, or specific terms. Lexicon is the name usually given to dictionaries of Greek, Hebrew, Arabic, Syriac, Ethiopic, and some other literary languages.

    [...]

    d. An ordered list stored in and used by a computer; spec. (a). a list of contents, e.g. of a database; (b). a list of words acceptable to a word-processing program, against which each word of text is checked.

  2. a. By extension: A book of information or reference on any subject or branch of knowledge, the items of which are arranged in alphabetical order; an alphabetical encyclopædia: as a Dictionary of Architecture, Biography, Geography, of the Bible, of Christian Antiquities, of Dates, etc.

    (Here the essential sense ‘word-book’ is supplanted by the accidental one of ‘reference book in alphabetical order’ arising out of the alphabetical arrangement used in modern word-books.)

lexicon

Etymology: ? mod.L., a. Gr. λεξικόν (sc. βιβλίον), neut. sing. of λεξικός of or for words, f. λέξι-ς diction, word, phrase, f. λεγ- to speak.

  1. a. A word-book or dictionary; chiefly applied to a dictionary of Greek, Hebrew, Syriac, or Arabic.

    The restricted use is due to the fact that until recently dictionaries of these particular languages were usually in Latin, and in mod.L. lexicon, not dictionarius, has been the word generally used.

    b. fig. (a). The vocabulary proper to some department of knowledge or sphere of activity; the vocabulary or word-stock of a region, a particular speaker, etc. (b). A list of words or names.
  2. Linguistics. The complete set of meaningful units in a language; the words, etc., as in a dictionary, but without the definitions. (Opp. GRAMMAR sb.)

vocabulary

Etymology: ad. med.L. vocābulāri-us, -um, f. L. vocābulum vocable sb.: see -ARY1 1. Hence also Ital., Sp., Pg. vocabulario, Fr. vocabulaire (1481). Cf. VOCABULAR sb., VOCABULER.

  1. a. A collection or list of words with brief explanations of their meanings; now esp. a list of this kind given in an elementary grammar or reading-book of a foreign language.

    Longer vocabularies are usually arranged alphabetically or according to subject-headings. In philological grammars and readers the vocabulary is commonly termed a glossary.

  2. a. The range of language of a particular person, class, profession, or the like.

    Used with limiting terms (possessives, adjectives, etc.).

  3. The sum or aggregate of words composing a language.

  4. fig. A set of artistic or stylistic forms, techniques, movements, etc.; the range of such forms, etc., available to a particular person, etc.

glossary

Etymology: ad. L. glossārium, f. glōssa GLOSS sb.1: see -ARY. Cf. Fr. glossaire.

A collection of glosses; a list with explanations of abstruse, antiquated, dialectal, or technical terms; a partial dictionary.

word-book

Etymology: f. WORD sb. + BOOK sb.; in sense 1 cf. G. wörterbuch (f. gen. pl. of wort word + buch book), Dutch †woordboek, woordenboek, Icel. orðabók, Sw. ordbok, Da. ordbog.

  1. A book containing a list of words (as of the vocabulary of a language, a book, an art, or science) arranged in alphabetical or other systematic order.

    The term is often used where it is desired to avoid the implication of completeness or elaboration of treatment characteristic of a dictionary or lexicon.

  2. The ‘book of the words’ or libretto of a musical composition. Again, this is just a small excerpt, but the parts I’ve shown should be clear enough.

Oh, and I threw glossary and word-book in because I knew you’d just come back and ask about them, since they are referenced in the other entries. As you can see, there is a lot of overlap in these words, particularly those defined in terms of one another. So even the OED contains what you might call circular references; this always happens with close word-sets like these.

However, there are also fine distinctions to be found and made, should one wish to do so.

  • 1
    +1 for the bolded usage note at the end of definition 1a of "dictionary"—about as succinct and accurate a description of the differences in meaning of the three terms as one could hope to find. – Sven Yargs Jan 4 '15 at 17:38

In its entry for dictionary, onomasticon, gazetteer, synonymicon, lexicon, wordbook, glossary, Webster's Dictionary of Synonyms (1942) offers this gloss on the words dictionary and lexicon:

Dictionary is now the usual term for a book which gives not only the words that belong to a language (or in an abridged dictionary, the most important and most common words of a language) but also their meanings, their accepted spelling or spellings, their pronunciation, etymology, and the like; as Webster's New International Dictionary of the English Language. It is also the general term applied to a book that embodies an alphabetical list of names with explanatory information or that presents an alphabetical list of terms with their synonyms; as ... a dictionary of synonyms, also, though rarely, called a synonymicon. ... Lexicon, though often used interchangeably with dictionary, especially as a name for the type (as, "In the lexicon of youth ... there is no such word As—fail!"—Lytton), is especially applied to a dictionary of an ancient language such as Greek, Hebrew, Sanskrit, or the like, originally with definitions in Latin but now usually in the vernacular. Consequently, lexicon is often, but not invariably, the preferred designation of a dictionary that interprets words of one language in terms of another,; as, a Latin-English lexicon; an English-French lexicon.

Webster's synonymicon parks its discussion of vocabulary under a different set of words—language, vocabulary, phraseology, phrasing, diction, style—with the predictable result that it doesn't address the dictionary-like sense of vocabulary:

Vocabulary, when used in reference to verbal expression, calls attention only to the extent or variety of the writer's or speaker's stock of words or to the sources from which such a stock is derived; [examples omitted].

As the OED coverage of the word in tchrist's answer indicates, however, vocabulary in the "dictionary" sense usually refers to a glossary or wordbook of not especially abstruse terms; it falls far short of a dictionary or lexicon in range and depth of coverage.

  • 1
    Oh drat, now we’re going to have to gloss gloss. :) – tchrist Jan 4 '15 at 18:28

Dictionary: a book that contains the words of a language in alphabetical order. The word Greek word lexicon means principally the same, but in English the standard term for books containing the words of a language is dictionary. In German the same thing is called Lexikon.

Vocabulary: a list of words contained in a text for the convenience of those who learn a language. If you study a text you can note down your own vocabulary list.

In linguistics specialists make a difference between the words that exist in a language and they have chosen the term lexicon. An individual doesn't use all the words of the dictionary. Only a small part is used. And for this part of words used by an individual person some linguists use "vocabulary". If you are a learner this linguistic use of the terms lexicon and vocabulary doesn't need to concern you. When you look up a word you use a dictionary.

Lexicon is a vocabulary specific to a 'thing' ie a strike is different in baseball and bowling, because it depends on what lexicon it is in

Vocabulary is all lexicons of one language combined ie strike will mean both definitions

Dictionary is a compilation of the vocabulary into an agreed upon 'definitions book'

Your Answer

 
discard

By clicking "Post Your Answer", you acknowledge that you have read our updated terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy, and that your continued use of the website is subject to these policies.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.