6

Specifically, I am referring to the traditional gesture some female service staff members seem to do, when demonstrating their work or their readiness to receive orders.

Also, this is the gesture Alice Cullen performs in Twilight movies on several occasions (if I remember correctly).

I could not find a photo with this exact gesture. It is similar to the one shown in the first photo, but the hands are held higher with demonstrativeness, tension, sharpness of movement and gesture itself (possibly with emotion and a smile), and military-like demeanor. The main difference with with the second photo is that in the gesture I refer to, the hands are held in the front and not in the back; also, the way the hands are interlocked is different (more like in the first picture).

a girl whose hands are crossed one over the other positioned in front of her apron a soldier whose hands are placed behind his back in the "parade rest" position

  • 1
    An example image would be helpful, if you can find one? – A E Nov 22 '14 at 20:34
  • 1
    @AE I could not find an image with this exact gesture, but I added two images with similar gestures and specified the difference with each of them. – Jake Nov 22 '14 at 21:22
  • 1
    Well, it ain't "akimbo"! – rhetorician Nov 22 '14 at 22:26
  • 1
    Could you not crop the first image, leaving only the hands clasped together visible? If you can't, I'll do it. EDIT: Better :) – Mari-Lou A Nov 22 '14 at 23:13
  • 2
    In my opinion, attempting to identify and name the hand pose you are seeking the label for is an exercise in futility without the benefit of a drawing or photo of the exact position in question. Can you get someone to take a photo of you holding your own hands in the position you are seeking to find the name for, and then edit your question accordingly? – Erik Kowal Nov 23 '14 at 8:08
2

My first posting here. This piqued my interest, to the point of actual Google hunting. :) I thought perhaps the style of hand clasp is similar to how singers hold their hands. Not sure if I've helped, hindered or befuddled.

http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/RecitationHandclasp

  • ... thus 'recitation handclasp' is your answer. I do not believe this is the correct answer. – lbf Aug 18 '18 at 14:30
5

two maids posing on a cruise deck woman dressed as female servant in 19th centuryillustration taken from " Body Language"

I'm posting images, so if anyone knows the correct terminology for these different hand gestures, because I've become curious myself, please post your answers.

For image No. 1, the person on the right is clasping or clenching her hands. In Image No. 2, I'd say she is holding her own hands. The caption for Image No. 3 reads: hands clenched in lower position.

Hand and Arm Gestures:
Research by Nierenberg and Calero on the hands-clenched position brought them to the conclusion that this was a frustration gesture, signalling that the person was holding back a negative attitude. The gesture has three main positions; hands clenched in front of the face, (Figure 39), hands resting on the desk (Figure 40) or on the lap when seated and placed in front of the crotch when standing (Figure 41).

Source: BODY LANGUAGE How to read others’ thoughts by their gestures by Allan Pease

  • I was only trying to help. Jeez... not looking for upvotes here! Don't give a damn about getting rep. It's called "let's see if we can help"! – Mari-Lou A Nov 23 '14 at 6:26
  • 2
    The website your citation links to contains a useful summary of some of the most common gestures and body postures that people use when communicating. In my view, the fact that the majority lack distinct names underlines how little conscious attention we give to them: most have to be identified by a literal description, and sometimes only a picture conveys with precision what a given position consists of. English, at least, appears to be pretty lacking in relevant terminology; I wonder if the languages of the supposedly eager-to-gesticulate people of the Mediterranean nations do a better job? – Erik Kowal Nov 23 '14 at 7:56
  • 1
    @ErikKowal even Googling those images was surprisingly difficult. I was and am at a loss as to how to describe the first person's hands, "left hand relaxed over right hand" doesn't quite cut it. Italians don't really have names for their hand gestures, they will say something like "What do want from me?" while closing the tips of all their fingers together, and shaking the hand back and fro. (Have I explained that gesture clearly?) It really needs an image. – Mari-Lou A Nov 23 '14 at 8:03
  • 1
    @TRomano - You don't think it would have been helpful to both the housekeeper and the maids to give a name to that gesture? "Girls! Hands in the XXX position! Now!" – Erik Kowal Nov 23 '14 at 18:09
  • 1
    If you do a Google image search for the phrase "hands clasped in front" you'll find many images showing similar positioning of hands, both with interlocking fingers, and with one hand covering the other. There are variations in wrist twisting, finger spread, shoulder altitude, and so forth. – barbecue Nov 25 '14 at 0:20
2

I don't think there's a single word that conveys the whole pose. Hands clasped covers the positioning of the hands relative to each other, either with fingers intertwined, or with one hand covering the other. But hands can also be clasped behind the back, or in prayer, and two people can clasp hands. So "hands clasped in front" is probably as good a phrase as there is.

  • I was looking for these expressions and seems like "Hands clasped in front" describes it very well. In my language (Hungarian) we have a word for this and most of the other hand gestures but they can't be translated properly to English. – user193963 Aug 30 '16 at 23:23
2

If you search for victorian maids in images, they don't seem to all be doing that gesture. On paintings of (hand)maidens, most of the time their hands are handling objects. Is that a specific pose or is that behavior? So I wondered specifically if maids - or women of a certain era - were taught to act in such a way or would they be generally so familiar with singing techniques as to spontaneously do a recitation handsclap in a - tenseful - way in different contexts. Consider these images:

enter image description here

Coronation of the Queen of England, Elizabeth II, 1953

I don't think there's any randomness here; this is an incredible show of power. Were the hand placement random it wouldn't be so twice on the same occasion. And the right hand overtaking the left comes as no surprise. This is I think a display of classic (British) etiquette. It also showcases an intuitive yet thorough understanding of the lexical, symbolic and cultural underpinnings associated with the (word) hand.

The hand

The NED provides insight: 3. In reference to action performed with the hand and hence (fig.) to action generally; thus often=agency, instrumentality[...]. - 5. As used in various ways of making a promise or oath; (spec.)[...] marriage. - 6. Hence, In oaths[...]. - 8. A person employed by any other in manual work. - 10. [...]a person[...] as the source from which something is obtained[...]+references to trust and best price. - 12. Horsemanship. - 20. A lineal measure. Usage of clean hands: freedom from wrongdoing, innocence and uprightedness of life. Of course there's come to hand, give one's hand etc. to no end. Considering the hand/arm are also heraldic symbols, and looking briefly at the countless religious references associated with cross, it's unlikely such a gesture is an attempt at crossing hands or fingers, especially not while mixing random colors.

The right hand

I think it's also easy to identify that historically in the Western world the left hand was always considered suspicious or "sinister" and treated very differently from the "right" hand(see right-handed, i.e. of the right kind). Within that frame of thought if one had to be shown it should be the right hand.

The grace of repose

And the end of the 19th "Victorian" sort of etiquette. Such as holding a fork with the right hand and having the Routledge tell you how to carve(lobster would have been useful) or that [w]ashing your hands in milk and water, for 2-3 days, will make them white. There is great care for "the unity of the hands". In a document I found the following:

The nervous toying with ear-rings or brooches, or dress buttons, is another mannerism to be guarded against. The hands should learn the grace of repose. It is a great triumph of nervous control[...]

It's about acting in a composed manner, showing composure. Surely the hands take part in a graceful composition.


A. Therefore I think this is about a display of honest, serving, dextrous hands, and what composed/mannered used to mean in the Victorian era, which may seem like mannerism today.

protected by tchrist Aug 18 '18 at 12:26

Thank you for your interest in this question. Because it has attracted low-quality or spam answers that had to be removed, posting an answer now requires 10 reputation on this site (the association bonus does not count).

Would you like to answer one of these unanswered questions instead?

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.