1

I've seen them used in almost similar circumstances, and I'm not sure what the difference is.

The victim cried out in despair.

He was a real idiot.

Are those vocatives, epithets, or neither?

Thanks!

5

My dictionary defines epithet as follows:

n. an adjective or phrase expressing a quality or attribute regarded as characteristic of the person or thing mentioned: old men are often unfairly awarded the epithet 'dirty'.

So I don't see how either of your examples qualifies as an epithet.

Vocative denotes a case of nouns, pronouns, and adjectives in Latin and other languages, used in addressing or invoking a person or thing.

Perhaps the most famous vocative of all time were the words Shakespeare attributed to Caesar as he was stabbed by the conspirators Et tu Brute (Even thou, O Brutus) - Brute being the vocative form of Brutus.

Hence I do not think either of your examples qualify either as epithets or vocatives.

  • Look out is either an imperative sentence, or an interjection, not a vocative, as it does not specify who should be doing the looking out - the very purpose and diagnostic feature of a vocative. Oh my toe is probably a misinterpretation of Ow, my toe!, an ejaculation - unless you are actually talking to your toe and expecting it to listen. English vocatives are not grammatically marked, but John in John, could you come here? is a vocative, as is you in Hey, you! (and certainly Caesar's Brutus in O Brutus). That said, I agree that the OP contains no vocatives whatsoever. – Amadan Nov 12 '14 at 1:03
  • @Amadan Thank you for that contribution. You are quite right and I have edited accordingly. It is over half a century now, since I studied Latin! – WS2 Nov 12 '14 at 9:09

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.