0

I understand that a serial comma (the one used before and/or) is used only when we have three or more items to be separated using and/or.

What exactly is the rule that governs where to add a comma before an and/or in a sentence such as the following:

  • S1: I went to John's house, and I watched a movie there.
  • S2: I went to John's house and there I watched a movie.
  • S3: Look around for any evidence that might reveal the identity of the intruder, and carefully place that evidence in a plastic bag, so it can be examined closely at headquarters.

I have seen S1 written both with and without comma. Which is correct; why?

What would be the right way to punctuate S2; why?

Should there be a comma before so in S3 or not; why/why not?

2

Generally speaking, you want to use a comma in sentences made of two independent clauses connected by one of the following seven coordinating conjunctions: and, but, for, or, nor, so, yet.

Don't use commas between an independent and dependent clause UNLESS the dependent clause shows extreme contrast.

So, in the S1, there are two independent clauses connected by AND. Use a comma. In S2, again we have two independent clauses connected with AND. Use a comma. In S3, you have correctly punctuated the sentence according to the rules listed above (independent clause AND independent clause SO independent clause). However, you created a run-on sentence, so at least one of those clauses should be made into its own sentence.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.