0

When I see examples of 'must' or 'will' showing certainty, I find that the main verb is either a stative verb or a present participle preceded by 'be'. How different are the two sentences in the following pairs:

He will be coming (now). VS He will come (now).
He must be working. VS He must work. 

Can we use 'must' to express future certainty like 'will'?

1

With a stative verb, "must" expresses necessity; with a non-stative verb, "must" expresses obligation. This is parallel to the two senses of "may", which expresses possibility with a stative, but permission with a non-stative. Sometimes the obligation/permission senses are referred to as "moral" senses, and logicians call this "deontic". Linguists have called the necessity/possibility senses "epistemic", but to a logician "epistemic" concerns knowledge and belief.

I don't see a parallel with "will".

You get the necessity/possibility interpretations with progressives, and also with perfects, but that is really a special case of the rule for statives, since although progressive goes only with a non-stative verb, the progressive itself is stative. A perfect is also stative.

0

Both "He will be coming (now)" and "He will come (now)" express similar expectations about a future occurrence and seem to me to be virtually interchangeable.

But as Armen Ծիրունյան observes in a comment above, "He must be working" is idiomatically quite different from "He must work." The latter sentence simply states a necessity; but idiomatically, the former sentence is speculative. In a particular context, the speculation might take this form:

He's not here when he said he would be, so he must be working later than he thought he'd have to.

There is no actual necessity implied by a surmise expressed in this form. Merriam-Webster's Eleventh Collegiate Dictionary (2003) defines the relevant sense of must as follows:

4 : be logically inferred or supposed to {it must be time}

In this idiomatic usage, the thing that "must" be true is necessarily true only if the underlying logic or supposition is justified.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.