4

I'm just trying to figure out if "neither I" is grammatically correct as a standalone statment (in spoken English).

  • 1
    ‘Nor I’ is correct. – Toothrot Oct 28 '15 at 20:24
5

No, it is grammatically unacceptable.

Correct constructions using neither include:

  • Neither a nor b: This is the most common usage.

    Neither Alaska nor Florida charges state income tax.

  • Neither noun: You can use this variant when it's clear what you are referring to.

    I moved from Alaska to Florida this year. Fortunately, neither state charges income tax.

  • Me neither: This may be close to what you had in mind.

    "I don't like Brussels sprouts."

    "Me neither."

  • Neither: This could be a one-word sentence.

    "Do you prefer carrots or broccoli?"

    "Neither."

-1

As I said, I already heard "Neither I". If it would be grammaticaly incorrect indeed, this is the contraction for "Neither (do) I" where the verb is implicit like in : "he's faster than I" for than I am...

We also have :"Neither I nor Bruce could handle it" where a third part would also say : "Neither I" for "Nor I" or "me neither" or "me either I could not" BUT NOT "me either I could" to mean "could not" because with the negative "either" can't match here...

But we've worst like : He DO or "my baby just CARE for me" in the song...

  • 1
    This site is for learning English; we should model proper usage in our answers. – Feathercrown Apr 10 '17 at 22:16

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.