I have a problem to rewrite the sentence, "I passed a good week with you." I thought of "I spent a good week with you." or "I had a good week with you." The direction says not to change the wording or meaning of the original sentence so much. Are my sentences grammatically okay? Does it sound naturally to native people? If there is a better way to say so, please let me know. Thank you.
closed as off-topic by tchrist♦, Chenmunka, Robusto, user66974, FumbleFingers Sep 17 '14 at 12:45
- This question does not appear to be about English language and usage within the scope defined in the help center.
This sounds like a homework question where you need to rewrite various sentences that are phrased a bit ungainly or unnaturally.
"Passing a good week" certainly qualifies as both ungainly and unnatural. Even though pastimes are things we do to pass the time away, saying "I passed a good week with you" sounds too much like a bad biological experience that eventually, ummm, passed.
Your first alternative, using "spent" rather than "passed" is perfectly valid. In this context, "spend" is a synonym for "pass." Your second alternative is also valid. I like the first alternative better than the second, but that's just personal preference.
There is a potential problem with your rewrite. You are interpreting "good week" as a week during which a number of nice events occurred. A very different interpretation of "I passed a good week with you" is possible. Idiomatically, "passing time" has an air of indolence to it. When we "pass the time away" we might as well be just twiddling our thumbs. With this interpretation, that good week was something wasted rather than something to be remembered fondly. A rewrite that captures this sense of passage of time is
I wasted a good week with you!
The above sentence has a very different meaning than "I spent/had a good week with you".
I think your meaning is entirely clear. Your construction is similar to "We passed time by playing cards". I can see no need to alter it.
I spent a good week, or I had a good week, or I enjoyed a good week, would all be equally clear but are no better than "passed".