3

Which sentence makes sense, the first or the second?

  1. I am      legend.
  2. I am  a  legend.
  • 3
    Are you thinking of the film I am Legend and/or 1954 novel and asking yourself why it was called that? Both sentences make sense according to context. If I am talking about the movie it's 1); if I am boasting about myself it's 2). – Mari-Lou A Aug 24 '14 at 3:47
  • This is just an ELL question. The simple answer is it is normally "I am a legend." The other version is (let's put it this way) poetic or dramatic; basically "it's wrong" if you said that normally, in speech. – Fattie Aug 24 '14 at 11:17
  • 1
    @JoeBlow I was inclined to think ELL too, but "I am legend" is actually correct and means something distinct from "I am a legend". It's just not something you'd hear every day, like you wouldn't hear "I committed genocide" every day. Dramatic, yes, wrong, no. (Well, genocide would be wrong.) – Daniel Aug 25 '14 at 0:03
  • TBC, it's wrong in the sense that: it is not what he meant. Quite simply, he's trying to say "I am a legend", not "I am legend" (you have explained nicely what the latter means). – Fattie Aug 25 '14 at 8:22
6

Either works, but they have different meanings, and I am a legend is probably the one you want.

Legend (Dictionary.com) means:

1. a nonhistorical or unverifiable story handed down by tradition from earlier times and popularly accepted as historical.

6. a collection of stories about an admirable person.

7. a person who is the center of such stories
"She became a legend in her own lifetime."

I am a legend would use definition 7 above, meaning that I am an amazing person.

I am legend would use definition 1 or 6 above, and would mean that I embody unverifiable history or myth, that my whole existence is shrouded in fable. This isn't a normal thing to say. While this concept is too stilted or dramatic for usual speech, there is a 1954 novel and a 2007 movie called I Am Legend, along these very lines.

It's confusing whether you meant to ask about a vs. an, since the question doesn't include this debate, but you should never say I am an legend, as a is always used before a consonantal sound.

2

The phrase

I am legend

is a case of the use of legend as a collective noun.

For example of such cases
  • Legend has it that your orgasm lasts an hour.
  • You are legend, in office-talk about your record.
  • She is orgasm, because she makes every man in the office get an instant boner.
  • She is honey, delectable and sweet.
  • I am furniture to my boss. He uses the electronic roster to tell me what to do, without telling me what to do.
  • Soil is essential to the growth of plants - well irrigated, aerated and nutrient-absorbent soil.
  • I am Revolution, Evolution, Convolution and Truth. No one comes to the gods but by me.

Sorry for the pornographic phrases, with which many might be familiar, to tickle your mind.

  • 1
    Good Lord! Someone rate this answer "X". – Fattie Aug 24 '14 at 11:19
  • 1
    I am 'sexually frustrated' – Pogrindis Aug 24 '14 at 13:07

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.