13

I have a book that explains how to speak in standard American English (American Accent Training — Barron's).

What does the term standard American English refer to?

Is there a region in the United States of America that has a pronunciation similar, or closer to standard American English (in the same way standard Italian is derived from a dialect spoken in Tuscany)?

  • From the answers so far, it turns out that there is no set 'Standard' that can be referenced for the purpose of defining Standard AmE. Or is it? – Kris Oct 19 '12 at 7:54
25

“Standard” American English (SAE), when used to describe accents, is identical to the term “General American English”, and means American English spoken without any clear regional dialect markers. Sociolinguists tell us that this means essentially English spoken in the north midlands region, like Iowa, but in reality it is spoken all over the country, even in places where many people speak with what others would describe as “heavy” or “thick” accents. SAE is the English used by most television and radio broadcasters—that is, those who don’t speak with an identifiable regional accent.

In truth, a “standard” American accent is defined more by what it isn’t than what it is. It does not have the Northern Cities Vowel Shift, New England non-rhoticity, features of New York English, or any of the phonological features of Southern American English.

There is some debate as to whether speakers with or without the cot-caught merger (that is, whether or not the words cot and caught are pronounced differently) are speaking SAE, but most would consider that not a defining characteristic of SAE.

  • +1 for a “standard” American accent is defined more by why it isn’t than what it is. – Kris Oct 19 '12 at 7:52
10

Some people will point to the Midwest as the location where Standard American English is spoken. But, most dialectology work has found that there is no region without a regional accent (for example see the Atlas of North American English).

For the most part, when your average commentator, or even a linguist, refers to Standard American English, what they mean is "speech which has no salient regional or dialectal markers." That is, Standard American English is largely negatively defined. There is no x such that Standard English sounds like x. Rather there is a, b and c such that Standard English does not sound like a, b or c.

2

First of all (as an American), I have no idea what "standard American" means--there are distinct regionalisms, but no one of them is "standard." While it's probably not disputed that there's an American dialect (usage, spelling, etc.), there's no "standard" American accent.

Off the top of my head, I can think of a number of regional accents (Northeastern, Southern, Midwestern) that can be broken down further (Texas has an accent that is distinct from a deep Southern accent, even though both can be called "Southern"; Boston is known for its non-rhotic "r" sounds, but the same type of non-rhoticity can be found throughout northern New England).

As other answers have stated, there are distinct markers that identify particular regions that, when none are present, the speaker could be said to be speaking "without an accent".

0

I agree with the general answers. However, I would say that the Omaha, Nebraska area, would come to the closest thing we have to a geographic area where Standard American English (accent) is natively spoken. Having said that, there are hundreds of other places, from Ohio to Colorado to Seattle, where no "accent" that really identifies the place is evident (unless an intentionally regional expression is employed).

(Oh, and I am not from Omaha. I am from Wisconsin, where, though considered the MidWest, we definitely do have an identifiable "accent." :)

0

I've noticed that when people speak of "standard" American English, "No regional markers" generally unpacks as "no mergers that create homophones" such as cot/caught.

SAE is sometimes described as newsreader dialect on national TV. These guys have a functional requirement for maximum intelligibility over all dialect areas.

So I think there is principled a way of describing Standard American. It's how you speak when you express every vowel distinction in any dialect and don't drop consonants (in particular no non-rhotic dialect is ever described as SAE).

As others have pointed out, North Midlands without the recent Northern Cities Vowel shift is a common referent for SAE. So is the upper-middle-class (but not working-class) dialect in Philadelphia, where I live. Someone pointed out Nebraska which works too as long as it's a version without cot/caught merger.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.