1

Is survey just an Anglicisation of the loan-word surveil, or have the meanings split?

http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/survey and http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/surveil suggests that surveil is only used in the context of observing people, but considering they are pronounced the same (where I come from), I can't hear this difference in everyday usage.

  • The words may be related but do not mean the same at all. surveil to observe closely the activities of (a person or group) Origin: 1965–70; back formation from surveillance dictionary.reference.com/browse/surveil dictionary.reference.com/browse/surveillance – Kris Jul 31 '14 at 7:06
  • You've answered your own question by posting the definitions. You can clearly see the two words mean two different things in English. – ElendilTheTall Jul 31 '14 at 7:07
  • The terminal l is pronounced. ibid. – Kris Jul 31 '14 at 7:08
  • No word surveil appears in Oxford Dictionaries. It appears in the OED with references from 1960 to 1972. The second of those references is from a British newspaper, The Guardian. But I have never heard or seen it used as a verb in Britain, only in the form of the abstract noun surveillance, perhaps for the obvios reason that it is too easy to confuse with survey. – WS2 Jul 31 '14 at 7:24
  • @WS2 "To try to advance critical awareness and to surveil corporate and political surveillers are important political moves for guaranteeing civil rights, ..." books.google.co.in/… – Kris Jul 31 '14 at 11:47
2

The Columbia Guide to Standard American English (1993) confirms that surveil is a late addition to English:

Surveil is a fairly recent back-formation, a verb describing what a surveillant ("watcher," an even more recent coinage) does. All these terms are Standard, although some might consider surveil and surveillant primarily police and spy argot.

I ran a Google Books search for the infinitive form "to survey" (blue line) and all instances of "surveil" (red line) between 1700 and 2008. Here is the resulting Ngram chart:

In one isolated nineteenth-century instance, surveil appears as a French noun in the "Monthly Retrospect" column in The Tradesman; or, Commercial Magazine (April 1813):

Twenty of the merchants and other opulent inhabitants [of Osnaburg] had been seized previously to the departure of the garrison, and informed that they would be held responsible with their lives, for the good behaviour of their fellow-citizens, and they were every second day obliged to appear before the French surveil. We do not hesitate to affirm, that the fate of Europe hangs on the approaching campaign.

And in one early twentieth-century reference, it appears as an anglicized word. From a 1903 translation of Bernard Lazare, Antisemitism, Its History and Causes:

In Spain, where the mingling of Jews and Christians was considerable, the Inquisition was instituted by Gregory XI, who gave it its constitution, to surveil the judaizing heretics and the Jews and Moors, who, though not subjects of the Church, were subject to the will of the Holy Office whenever "by their words or their writings they urged the Catholics to embrace their faith."

But aside from those two outliers, the earliest earnest instance of surveil that a Google Books search finds is from General Education Journal (1968) [combined snippets]

It is good for interacting individuals to know what restrictions in their behavior exist. Once these restrictions are accepted, the people concerned are expected to control their own behavior in order to adhere to them and therefore the need for each to personally surveil the behavior of others is reduced. Unless people will feel an obligation to adhere to them, the need to personally surveil the behavior of others will not be reduced, and there will be no gain for one to abide by such rules.

I specified "earnest," because Lyndall Urwick, "The Meaning of Control," in Michigan Business Review (November 1960) specifically denies that the word exists, though by identifying it he in some sense creates a precedent for its use:

But naughty, careless Mr. Coubrough! His "little sin" has "misguided a large segment of a generation of English-speaking management theorists." He would have served us better by translating contrôler as "measure," or "compare," or "check up," or "verify," or "inspect." The ideal solution would have been "surveillance." Unfortunately, there is no English verb "to surveil," though "this need not be a decisive deterrent."

A Google Books search finds single additional instances of surveil in 1969, 1970, and 1972, all at U.S. Congressional hearings, and many more thereafter. It seems fairly clear to me that surveil became established in U.S. English usage through its adoption and use by government agencies—spy and otherwise.

Meanwhile, a Google Books search finds matches for "to survey" going back to Thomas Lodge, Rosalynde, or Euphues Golden Legacie (1592), the source of the main plot in As You Like It:

For my selfe thou knowest, though I am eldest by birth, yet never having attempted any deeds at Arms I am yongest to performe any martial exploytes, knowing better how to survey my lands than to charge my Launce; my brother Fernandyne hee is at Paris poring on a fewe papers, having more insight into Sophistrie and principles of Philosiophie, then anie warlyke endeveurs; but thou, Rosader, the youngest in years but the eldest in valour, art a man of dtrength, and darest doo what honour allowes thee:

...

Saladyne, hearing this shepheardesse speake so wisely, began more narrowly to pry into her perfection, and to survey all her liniaments with a curious insight; so long dallying in the flame of her beautie, that to his cost he found her to be most most excellent:

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.