0

He left home young

He died young

Does the word "young" act as either a predicative complement or a incidental adverbial in those sentences?And how to distinguish them?

2

1 Answer 1

3

It is not always simple to distinguish adverbial from adjectival usage in this sort of construction. Is the word in question saying something more about the (often subject) noun, or about the action/process?

In 'he hammered the metal flat', 'flat' is a predicative adjective showing the final state of the metal. This is a resultative construction.

In 'he hammered the metal frenziedly', 'frenziedly' is an adverb adding description to the verb[al action].

In 'he shot wide', it is arguable whether 'wide' is describing the final situation (of the ball's position) or the woeful manner of shooting. 'Wide' can be a flat adverb (eg 'travelled far and wide').

However, in 'he died young', 'young' is obviously not telling us anything (directly) about the manner of his death, but something about his condition when he died: ie 'young' modifies the (subject) pronoun, and this is therefore a subject-orientated depictive construction, with 'young' an adjective.

2
  • Better late than never! I wouldn't say that "young' modifies the subject "he", though it does relate to it. Complement and Modifier are distinct functions, and items like "young" in your example are subject-oriented complements (not modifiers). Btw. a more accurate term for "young" is predicative adjunct: predicative because it relates to a predicand ("he") and adjunct because it's a modifier in clause structure.
    – BillJ
    Commented Feb 4 at 18:35
  • Yes, I was using the older broader sense of 'modify' meaning 'somehow qualifies'. Commented Feb 4 at 19:49

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.