-3

I am starting to use evocative and provocative interchangeably. I would like to understand the difference between these words and when one should be used instead of the other.

although the definitions of these words are readily available, I am looking for an explanation for when one word should be used instead of the other.

closed as off-topic by tchrist, FumbleFingers, anongoodnurse, user66974, choster Jul 21 '14 at 5:28

This question appears to be off-topic. The users who voted to close gave this specific reason:

  • "Questions that can be answered using commonly-available references are off-topic. A list of these references can be found here: List of general references" – tchrist, FumbleFingers, anongoodnurse, Community, choster
If this question can be reworded to fit the rules in the help center, please edit the question.

  • 1
    One evokes; the other provokes. – tchrist Jul 20 '14 at 17:23
  • That sounds like the difference between an internal and an external stimulation. My initial though says that this difference is very subjective (this is probably at the root of my problem). How do I get past this? – Hoytman Jul 20 '14 at 17:29
  • 4
    Cast your mind back to the time before you started treating these two words as interchangeable. If you can't remember why you used them in different contexts with different meanings, consult a dictionary to refresh your memory. – FumbleFingers Jul 20 '14 at 17:30
  • @tchrist said it. Nothing more to say. – Drew Jul 21 '14 at 1:39
  • Evocative is relatively new in my vocabulary. I heard a preacher use it. – Hoytman Jul 21 '14 at 2:33
2

Since my excessively heavy dictionary (American Heritage Dictionary, 4th Edition) is already out, I might as well see what it has to say on the subject.

evoke tr.v. evoked, evoking, evokes 1. To summon or call forth: actions that evoked our mistrust. 2. To call to mind by naming, citing, or suggesting: songs that evoke old memories. 3. To create anew, especially by means of the imagination: a novel that evokes the Depression in accurate detail. [Latin evocare, to call.]

Synonyms evoke, educe, elicit These verbs mean to draw forth or bring out something latent, hidden, or unexpected.

So, basically, evoke means to call to mind, to create internally. When an author evokes the wind, they create the feeling or image of the wind in the mind of the person reading the text. You can also evoke things by accident - a beautiful melody can evoke a memory of the time your mother taught you to play the piano, although the musician may not have intended to do so.

provoke tr.v -voked, -voking, -vokes 1. To incite to anger or resentment. 2. To stir to action or feeling. 3. To give rise to; evoke: provoke laughter. 4. To bring about deliberately; induce: provoke a fight. [Middle English provoken, from Old French provoquer, from Latin provocare, to challenge.]

Synonyms provoke, incite, excite, stimulate, arouse, rouse, stir These verbs mean to move a person to action or feeling or to summon something into being so by moving a person. Provoke often merely states the consequences produced: "Let my presumption not provoke thy wrath" (Shakespeare).

Note that in the definition of provoke, the word evoke is cited, but only in one of the four uses. These words are very similar. The main difference between them is the fact that provoke has lots of negative connotations attached to it. You generally won't see people provoking someone to hug other people, but instead to punch them in the face. It's related to the Latin root meaning challenge, which adequately describes the general antagonistic effect desired by the use of the word provoke.

As the other answers mentioned, provoking is generally a very physical thing. It involves words, actions, physical stimuli. Evoking, on the other hand, is generally very related to feelings, thoughts, and memories. It tends to be much more emotional.

Provoke is also distinct in that it requires an external provoker. You can evoke something within your mind all on your own - no external intent is required for the whistling of the wind through the trees to call to mind the time you stood on the moor and watched your house burn down as the howling wind brought the ashes to you.

However, external intent is required to provoke - you need a taunter for cruel words to drive you to punch them in the face. You have to have a provoker, and they have to intend to provoke you. (Alternately, you could just assume they mean to provoke you... the whale in Moby Dick didn't really intend to provoke Captain Ahab, he's just crazy enough to believe that it did. As long as intent is assumed, provoking can happen.)

You do not need an evoker to evoke emotions, and the evoker may not even intend to create emotion within the listener. A singer may desire to stir people to tears, but if an audience member is crying because the melody evokes the last song she sang before she lost her voice in a tragic accident, that is unrelated to the intent of the singer.

(All examples were created on the spot by the author.)

2

'evocative' (adj.)--tending or serving to evoke (to bring to mind or recollection). e.g., 'this place evokes memories of happier years.' Provocative' (adj.)--serving or tending to provoke, excite or stimulate. e.g., a very attractive woman wearing a black, backless dress with deep decolletage I would find extremely provocative. But It wouldn't stir up past memories of other women in black, backless dresses with deep decolletages. I think the difference is 'evocative' stirs one's recollections and 'provocative' stirs one's sensory faculties.

  • Where are the definitions from? Always clearly format quotes as such, and always properly attribute them. Mods are instructed to delete unattributed content on sight. – RegDwigнt Jul 20 '14 at 21:43
1

You can provoke thoughts and actions, but you generally evoke only thoughts/memories.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.