4

This question already has an answer here:

In the aftermath of the space shuttle Challenger explosion, where seven crew members were killed, the NASA program underwent a massive examination of priorities.

My SAT grammar book claims that where is incorrect and should be replaced with in which.

I tried googling the difference, and the answers have been saying those two are practically the same. I was wondering if it was not the case with this sentence?

marked as duplicate by tchrist, Mitch, FumbleFingers, user66974, Ronan Jul 7 '14 at 10:16

This question has been asked before and already has an answer. If those answers do not fully address your question, please ask a new question.

  • 1
    Where formally means at which (place). It sometimes assumes the role of other preposition + which combinations. – Anonym Jul 6 '14 at 22:28
  • I have seen that question before posting, and I posted this question for clarification. The answers there denoted that both could be used, and I just wanted to see if this sentence would be different since the book says it is wrong to use "where" but correct for "in which" – stumped Jul 7 '14 at 1:34
9

There is no reason in The Language Herself why you should not use where in this sentence.

There are to be sure people who will tell you that where can only refer to an actual spatial place, and cannot be extended to “figurative locations”, such as states and situations and events, for which you must use in which.

But the in of in which referring to a state or situation is already a “figurative” use of a locative preposition. And states and situations and events are themselves “figurative locations”: your “situation” is the “site” where you find yourself, your “state” is the “place” where something has “stood” you, and an “event” is something which has “arrived from” somewhere to the place where you stand in time.

Why on earth should you avoid using a figurative locative to refer to a figurative location?

The only grounds for avoiding this use is to satisfy an audience comprised mostly of people who hold the absurd opinion that the use is “wrong”. Alas, the composers of Standardized Tests are mostly people of that sort, who were taught this “rule” as small children and never acquired sufficient grasp of The Language to realize its absurdity. Consequently you should avoid the use when you are taking the test; but feel free to ignore it otherwise.

0

The reason being that they are referring to the situation, rather than the place.

The accident, in which seven people were injured.... My city, where I grew up.....

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.