0

In the sentence below, is nice a subject complement, verb complement, or both?

She seems nice.

According to this page, it’s a type of verb complement; but it also seems to me to fit with the description of a subject complement, as explained on this page.

1

The most traditional terminology is that verbs like seem are linking verbs that link the subject (or object) with their corresponding subject/object complements. A subject/object complement is also known as a predicative.

Predicatives are also complements to the linking verb, though: they are part of the predicate in the sentence. (With the verb be, in fact, they are the predicate, and the verb itself is just an empty placeholder that has to be there for the sentence to be grammatical.)

So the simple answer to your question is both. A subject complement or subject predicative is automatically a complement to the main verb in the clause, if there is one.

1

In the sentence below, there are all kinds of names for what nice is.

  • She seems nice.

But the sentence above has been done things to. An equivalent sentence is

  • She seems to be nice.

from which the first sentence is derived by To-be-Deletion.

In other words, there is an infinitive complement here.
And (be) nice is its predicate adjective.
What you want to call nice after to be is deleted is up to you.

I won't go into A-Raising here, but seem is a prototypic A-Raising verb,
since what actually seems in this sentence is in fact not her, and not nice, but rather
that she is nice.

That she is nice is also a possible complement clause with seem, although it requires Extraposition.

  • It seems that/like she is nice.

And it means the same as the other sentences.

  • I keep finding references saying verbs like be, become, seem are copulas (apparently the same thing as linking verbs). Does that imply any special significance to the fact that one "expanded" version of OP's example actually contains two such verbs? – FumbleFingers Jun 3 '14 at 15:18
  • Yeah, that's what they used to be called, because it looked like they behaved the same way as be. But it turns out that be is an auxiliary but seem is a real verb that takes real complements. You realize there was no systematic study of English syntax before about 1950; it was largely ignored, or treated only in simple SVO sentences. – John Lawler Jun 3 '14 at 17:09

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.