0

Is "leading" a superlative adjective? In the following sentence, does "leading" mean "best"?

China's leading singer, Xue is holding a concert today.

Should I necessarily say "one of China's leading singers" so that I do not end up meaning "China's best singer"?

4 Answers 4

2

Leading is an adjective and can be used in a number of ways. In the first example, you are trying to say that he/she is the most important singer in China. In the second, you are trying to pick him/her from a list of best singers in China.

Superlative means the highest form or quality of something. And the definition of highest could vary depending on context.

1

Yes. In a race the "leader" is the front-runner. "Leading" is the adjective version of this.

If you wish to say "China's leading singer" it is normal to include who has determined the leader like:

China's leading singer according to China Singer Magazine for 2014

However, "one of China's leading singers" is commonly used without attribution.

0

Yeah I think "leading" implies being ahead of everyone else, and if it's a tie, that should be made explicit by saying "one of." But I agree with Digital Chris (haha cool name), the word "leading" implies that there's a certain quantitative measure in which the singer exceeds all others. Without defining what that measure is exactly, sounds kinda wishy washy.

0

Grammar-wise the adjective "leading" is used in its positive form, not superlative. Not all adjectives have comparative/superlative forms (usually), while their meaning is an extreme of the kind - "unique", "infinite" and others.

"Leading" in your sentence can be viewed as one of such extremes. So you do imply that Xue is the best singer in China. This is a subjective opinion, that's why it's better to stick to "one of the leading singers", unless you want to provide some statistics, saying:

China's leading singer (according to the X poll / according to the number of concert attendees), Xue, is holding a concert today.

1
  • Yes. The term 'extreme adjective', not the term 'superlative form of a gradable adjective', is what is required here. Even this is misleading, as 'leading' could mean 'one of the leading group' rather than 'the leader', as you say. Commented Mar 31, 2014 at 15:41

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .