- The bird has two yellow spots on its wings.
- The bird has a yellow spot on both wings.
Do they mean the same?
Which one describes more accurately the yellow spots of the following bird?
(Other alternatives are welcomed too).
English Language & Usage Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for linguists, etymologists, and serious English language enthusiasts. It only takes a minute to sign up.Sign up to join this community
The most accurate description would be a yellow spot on each wing.
Two yellow spots on its wings.
This would give me the idea that there might be two spots on each wing.
A yellow spot on both wings.
I think this is correct, and it does make clear to me that there is one spot on each wing, but it may also be read as one yellow spot extending over both wings.
The main thing is, when we are talking about birds, we know they generally have two wings. You might even describe it as:
A yellow spot on the wing.
And people would assume (as birds tend to have identical, if mirrored) wings, that this goes for all wings the bird possesses.
Another option, and I think the most readable, would be
A yellow spot on each wing.
I would avoid mentioning the total number of spots, as you will risk confusing people: does two spots mean two spots per wing or two spots per two wings.
As a long-time birder, I'd reject both in favor of "...yellow patch evident on wings during flight." But I'm guessing you just selected 'birds' as a random "prop" for your usage question.
“Two yellow spots on its wings”
This is vague, as it could mean two spots on each wing, or two spots in total, on its wings. Replace the word "two" with "three" and it'd be even more confusing: three spots on each, or two on one, one on the other?
“a yellow spot on both wings?”
This is also vague, as it could mean one spot on each wing, or one spot which spans across both wings. However, if you replace the word "a" with "three" on this phrase, it wouldn't be complicated: three spots on both wings quite clearly means three spots on each wing.
In short, the latter phrase is slightly less complicated, but it is recommended to simply say "a yellow spot on each wing".
Thank you for your interest in this question.
Because it has attracted low-quality or spam answers that had to be removed, posting an answer now requires 10 reputation on this site (the association bonus does not count).
Would you like to answer one of these unanswered questions instead?