8

I designed a logo for a client. He liked the idea it presented, but wanted to see alternative ways to represent its idea, so I came up with several new designs of similar concept. I now have to package the new designs into a presentation document, and when it came to titling its sections, I wondered: are the new designs variants of the initial one, or are they variations?

  • In your context, only a pedant would claim any difference. In other contexts, variant can be an adjective, but variation can't. – FumbleFingers Jan 30 '14 at 1:11
  • They are variations not variants. Give it a thought and read your question (the specific case) and wonder why. The choice is easy so I am not telling it right away. – Kris Jan 30 '14 at 6:18
  • Only after fruitlessly puzzling over it did I post the question in the first place, @Kris. Even after a re-read, I would guess variant, if I had to pick one, as that sounds more like a specific element, e.g. a logo design, rather than the action of the design being made. (As I understand cHao to be saying.) But I get side-tracked wondering whether the logos can consistently claim either term, or whether it all depends on how I'm constructing the sentence in which I refer to them. All that to say, I don't see how you got to your conclusion. I hope you're willing to share. – Eve Jan 31 '14 at 3:00
12

Very strictly speaking, variation is change, and a variant is one of the forms resulting from the change.

The use of variation to mean variant is so common, though, that only a hardcore pedant would ever even recognize a difference in that context, much less say either one is incorrect.

  • 2
    Even a pedant might choke on "variants on a theme" rather than "variations on a theme". – user24964 Jan 30 '14 at 1:38
  • 1
    @TheMathemagician: Indeed. But he'd typically say "variants of a theme" instead, if he were pedantic enough to recognize a difference between the two words in this context. – cHao Jan 30 '14 at 1:39
  • Makes sense. Though by these definitions, it's hard to think of an example use case of the word variation in everyday speech. I can see it in a technical context, e.g., "The number of letters in American first names has a higher variation this decade than last." But can you provide some colloquial examples? – chharvey Sep 2 '16 at 18:01
  • @chharvey: The phrase "variations on a theme", as mentioned in these comments, is rather common. Others don't immediately jump out at me, but some dictionaries have examples. (Merriam-Webster, for one, gives the example "the movie begins with a somewhat irreverent variation on the Nativity story".) There's more examples of variation as change. Either way, it does seem more a highbrow word. – cHao Sep 12 '16 at 1:05
  • 1
    Is there a parallel between mutation and mutant? Because that's easy for me to understand. Mutants (X-Men, turtles, etc.) are the results of mutations (changes) to their DNA. – istrasci May 15 '17 at 18:24
3

A variation is something that differs from a standard or from something considered normal, while a variant differs from other things in its own class--that is, it's not something that necessarily differs from a norm or standard. Source: Garner's Modern American Usage.

3

Coming from a technical perspective, if I report that I tackled a problem using a variant of Algorithm A, then this variant is most likely one that other people have used before and there is literature on its use. If instead I say I was using a variation of Algorithm A, then the existing variants of Algorithm A didn't meet the particular requirements of my problem and I therefore needed to create my own adaptation. People after me might decide to call this a variant of Algorithm A, if they deem it close enough to the original.

Caution: I'm not a native English speaker.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.