0

The following is a dialogue of an animated movie (A bug's life), I don't understand why one of them says "Is too" instead of saying "it is". Is a this a natural way of responding and insisting on what you're implying?

-Oh, being little's not such a bad thing.
+Yes, it is.
-No, it's not.
+Is too!
-Is not.
+Is too.
-Is not.
+Is too.

  • It's a duplicate, if I remember it right. Please check previous posts. – Kris Dec 14 '13 at 5:19
  • 1
    It's teen lingo/ kid lingo, by the way. – Kris Dec 14 '13 at 5:20
2

These forms of contradictory retort (often heard from children)...

"it is [so] too"

"but it is"

"it is but"

...seem to have a "but" or "too" therein for emphasis. It might not have Germanic routes but it brought to mind aber in German for me, which in particulate form sometimes serves as a sort of surprise or emphasis (link provided for some clarity on this if interest arises - sorry it's not entirely committal emphasis, but I've heard as much from speakers). Of course "is too" also could be roughly compared with in truth and indeed in English; more emphasis.

I'm not sure how this form of 'argumentative' emphasis became a cliched juvenile retort - like anything and everything, perhaps through meme and repetition. Then, once denoted as a children's mode of speech it no doubt lost favour (and rhetorical credibility) among adults.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.