0

In the sentence: Her voice sounds beautiful. She sang the song exactly as it was written. We heard it perfectly. Isn't it feasible to substitute the last word by "perfect"? In Spanish both ways are valid but sounds better the second option. Even more, I feel that the second/third sentence can be deleted without grammatical ambiguity. Bye.

1
  • 2
    I think a native speaker would be more likely to say It sounded perfect; to hear perfectly describes your hearing, not the singer or the song.
    – choster
    Commented Nov 14, 2013 at 16:38

2 Answers 2

1

Grammatically perfect may replace beautiful, but it does not necessarily have the same meaning (which is what I think you are asking). Her singing voice may be beautiful to the ear, but still have faults, especially if it is a singing teacher who says this!

If you mean perfect to replace perfectly, the answer is no. Sound is one of those verbs like seem, appear, look which may take an adjectival complement, but most verbs cannot; in particular *hear it perfect is not grammatical.

As for deleting the second and third sentences: there is no grammatical ambiguity in doing so, but it removes a corresponding part of the meaning.

0

Do you mean the last word of the first sentence? If so, yes. 'Her voice sounds perfect' is good grammar. In this instance 'perfect' is an adjective describing 'her voice'. see choster's comment above.

You must log in to answer this question.