English Language & Usage Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for linguists, etymologists, and serious English language enthusiasts. It only takes a minute to sign up.
Sign up to join this community
This is the question:
A: Does she have many books?
B: ................. She only has two books.a. Yes, she does.
b. No, she does not.
My answer is B, am I wrong? My friend absolutely stands to say that my answer is wrong. He said that, two books are plural, even, there is a word "only". So, even only two books, it is included in plural, and the answer is A.
I'm really so confused.
(sourse: Use of the singular or plural "is" or "are" in ambiguous situations)
You need to define your terms, which is nearly equivalent to asking whether your friend is a maths nerd.
In maths, many is defined as (relating to) any counting number over 1, so, for instance, the inverse of the squaring function is a one-to-many relation, 4 mapping to both 2 and -2, and the fact that there are two images necessitating the term 'many'.
However, this is not the accepted everyday sense of the word many, and few mathematicians even would use it this way outside their studies. Peter Shor's comment gives the sensible everyday range of usage. And your answer 'B' is the only sensible one given the context.
